1958 Hall of Fame Election

200 of 266 votes needed for election

Player	Votes	Result
Max Carey	136
Edd Roush	112
Red Ruffing	99
Hack Wilson	94
Kiki Cuyler	90
Sam Rice	90
Tony Lazzeri	80
Luke Appling	77
Lefty Gomez	76
Burleigh Grimes	71
Red Faber	68
Lou Boudreau	64
Jim Bottomley	57
Joe Medwick	50
Pepper Martin	46
Hank Gowdy	45
Bucky Harris	45
Dave Bancroft	43
Lloyd Waner	39
Waite Hoyt	37
Chuck Klein	36
Johnny Vander Meer	35
Earle Combs	34
Stan Coveleski	34
Al Lopez	34
Bucky Walters	33
Eppa Rixey	32
Leo Durocher	28
Lefty O'Doul	27
Jimmy Dykes	26
Goose Goslin	26
Charlie Grimm	26
Bobby Doerr	25
Jesse Haines	22
Heinie Manush	22
Nick Altrock	20
Billy Southworth	18
Freddie Fitzsimmons	16
Paul Derringer	15
Dolf Luque	15
Earl Averill	14
Babe Herman	13
Art Nehf	13
Red Rolfe	13
Chick Hafey	12
Terry Moore	12
Schoolboy Rowe	12
Tommy Bridges	11
Joe Gordon	11
Tommy Henrich	11
Travis Jackson	11
Steve O'Neill	10
Muddy Ruel	10
Wes Ferrell	9
Joe Judge	9
Charlie Keller	9
Jack Quinn	9
Wally Schang	8
Birdie Tebbetts	8
Glenn Wright	8
Howard Ehmke	7
Billy Herman	7
Eddie Rommel	7
Stan Hack	6
Mel Harder	6
Pinky Higgins	6
Carl Mays	6
Pete Reiser	6
Charlie Root	6
Arky Vaughan	6
Cy Williams	6
Joe Bush	5
Frankie Crosetti	5
Joe Dugan	5
Orval Grove	5
Fielder Jones	5
Freddy Lindstrom	5
Firpo Marberry	5
Bob Meusel	5
Moe Berg	4
Max Bishop	4
Dolph Camilli	4
Cookie Lavagetto	4
Ernie Lombardi	4
Urban Shocker	4
George Uhle	4
Charlie Berry	3
Mort Cooper	3
Tony Cuccinello	3
Bill Doak	3
Lew Fonseca	3
Mike Gonzalez	3
Frankie Gustine	3
Willie Kamm	3
Bob O'Farrell	3
Luke Sewell	3
Bill Werber	3
Jimmie Wilson	3
Wally Berger	2
Ossie Bluege	2
Doc Cramer	2
Tommy Holmes	2
George Kelly	2
Ray Kremer	2
Freddy Leach	2
Joe McCarthy	2
Marty McManus	2
Lee Meadows	2
Van Lingo Mungo	2
Cy Perkins	2
Bill Sherdel	2
Lon Warneke	2
Earl Whitehill	2
Sparky Adams	1
Jimmy Austin	1
Dick Bartell	1
Larry Benton	1
Ray Blades	1
George Case	1
Sam Chapman	1
Alvin Crowder	1
Harry Danning	1
Curt Davis	1
Jumbo Elliott	1
Rick Ferrell	1
George Grantham	1
Mule Haas	1
Bill Hallahan	1
Bubbles Hargrave	1
Billy Jurges	1
Ken Keltner	1
Red Kress	1
Red Lucas	1
Gus Mancuso	1
Bing Miller	1
Wally Moses	1
Johnny Mostil	1
Charley O'Leary	1
Monte Pearson	1
Wally Pipp	1
Hal Schumacher	1
Jack Scott	1
Joe Sewell	1
Rip Sewell	1
Warren Spahn	1
Riggs Stephenson	1
Gus Suhr	1
Clyde Sukeforth	1
Rube Walberg	1
Harry Walker	1
Ken Williams	1
Whit Wyatt	1
Pep Young	1
Tom Zachary	1