Dave Bancroft

From BR Bullpen


David James Bancroft

Inducted into Hall of Fame in 1971

BR page


1916 M101-4

". . . the greatest shortstop the Giants ever had and one of the greatest that ever lived." - sportswriter and J.G. Taylor Spink Award winner Frank Graham

"Honus Wagner's successor as the National League's premier shortstop." - from Bancroft's SABR biography

". . . known for his intelligence on the field and his fiery leadership in the dugout . . . Bancroft is still considered to be among the top fielders in baseball history." - from Dave Bancroft's Hall of Fame website

Hall of Famer Dave Bancroft was a spark plug and team captain of the great New York Giants teams that won the pennant each year from 1921-1923. His assist and putout totals during the early 1920s are some of the highest of all time, and he was the first shortstop to turn 100 double plays in a season. While his batting was not as impressive as his fielding, his career Adjusted OPS+ is better than Hall of Fame shortstops Joe Tinker, Rabbit Maranville, Phil Rizzuto, Luis Aparicio, Ozzie Smith and John Ward, and he had more hits than Hall of Fame shortstops Lou Boudreau and Travis Jackson.

He was among the league leaders in walks eight separate times, was one of the league leaders in singles four times, doubles three times, triples once and home runs once. He was four times in the top three in the league in runs scored. And he was good with teams other than the Giants - he was twice in the top ten in MVP voting while playing for Boston teams in 1925-1926 that finished well under .500. As a rookie with the 1915 Phillies, he was second in the league in walks and and third in the league in runs scored, lifting the Phillies from a sixth-place finish in 1914 to a first-place finish in 1915.



Dave was born in Sioux City, IA, in 1891. After playing in the minors starting in 1909, he broke into the major leagues in 1915 with the Philadelphia Phillies, the year they played in their first World Series, hitting .254 in 153 games as a rookie. Bancroft played shortstop for the Phillies until 1920 when he was traded to the New York Giants at mid-season. He played for the Giants until the end of the 1923 season, when he was traded to the Boston Braves. With the Giants, Bancroft was part of the 1921 and 1922 World Series-winning team, hitting .318 in 153 games in 1921 and .321 in 156 games in 1922 as the team's regular shortstop; those were his two best seasons in the majors. Bancroft was a player-manager for the Braves for four seasons from 1924 until 1927. He then went to play for the Brooklyn Robins in 1928 and 1929. He ended his career in 1930, back with the Giants, and was a coach with the club from 1930 until 1932.

Bancroft was a career .279 hitter, and never hit more than seven home runs or drove in more than 67 runs in a season. His biggest accomplishments were his postseason success as a member of the 1921 and 1922 World Series champion Giants teams. He set a major league single season record in 1922 by handling 984 total chances at shortstop. He was, in fact, a very fine defensive player who led National League shortstops four times in putouts. In the 1920-1922 strech he was so dominant that he led the league in dWAR, every year. He was also very durable, playing over 100 games in 13 seasons, including a league-leading 156 in 1922.

Bancroft later managed three seasons in the minors. Additionally, he managed the Chicago Colleens in the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League in 1948 and the 1949-1950 South Bend Blue Sox.

Election to the Hall[edit]

Bancroft making a "sensational stop and throw" off Boston's Sherry Magee in 1915.

Bancroft was elected into the Baseball Hall of Fame on January 31, 1971 by the Veterans Committee. He is considered one of the most controversial players in the Hall, with many attributing his election to the presence of cronies on the Veterans Committee, notably former Giants teammate Frankie Frisch, rather than his baseball achievements. Most players with similar statistics do not have much of a chance of being elected to the Hall of Fame.

That is just one side of the argument, though. The other side of the argument is that Bancroft was the Ozzie Smith of his era - except he was Ozzie's equal in fielding but a better hitter. While Ozzie's record-setting assist total in 1980 (in 158 games) beat anything Bancroft (or anyone else) accomplished, Bancroft's assist totals in 1920 and 1922 both beat Ozzie's second-best season. And Bancroft's third best is almost exactly the same as Ozzie's third-best season. As far as hitting, Bancroft's best single-season Adjusted OPS+ of 120 easily beats Ozzie's best of 112, and Bancroft's lifetime Adjusted OPS+ bests the lifetime score of several shortstop Hall of Famers such as Ozzie, Joe Tinker, Rabbit Maranville, Luis Aparicio, Phil Rizzuto and John Ward, not to mention defensive whiz and Hall of Fame second baseman Bill Mazeroski. And Bancroft's score is only one point short of Hall of Fame shortstop Pee Wee Reese's score.

Notable Achievements[edit]

Preceded by
Fred Mitchell
Boston Braves Manager
Succeeded by
Jack Slattery

Year-by-Year Managerial Record[edit]

Year Team League Record Finish Organization Playoffs Notes
1924 Boston Braves National League 53-100 8th Boston Braves
1925 Boston Braves National League 70-83 5th Boston Braves
1926 Boston Braves National League 66-86 7th Boston Braves
1927 Boston Braves National League 60-94 7th Boston Braves
1933 Minneapolis Millers American Association 86-67 2nd none Lost League Finals
1936 Sioux City Cowboys Western League 5th none none replaced Marty Berghammer
1947 St. Cloud Rox Northern League 48-71 7th New York Giants
1948 Chicago Colleens AAGPBL 47-77 9th none
1949 South Bend Blue Sox AAGPBL 75-36 1st (t) none Lost League Finals
1950 South Bend Blue Sox AAGPBL 55-55 5th none

Records held[edit]

  • Fielding chances by a shortstop, season: 984 (1922)

Further Reading[edit]

  • Tom Alesia: Beauty at Short: Dave Bancroft, the Most Unlikely Hall of Famer and His Wild Times in Baseball’s First Century, Grissom Press, 2022. ISBN 978-0-5783-7451-2

Related Sites[edit]

Some or all content from this article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Dave Bancroft". Some of this material is not from Wikipedia.