1960 Hall of Fame Election

202 of 269 votes needed for election. As all candidates fell short of the mark and the Veterans Committee failed to elect anyone, there were no new Hall of Famers that year. This would be the last time this happened until 2021.

Player	Votes	Result
Edd Roush	146
Sam Rice	143
Eppa Rixey	142
Burleigh Grimes	92
Jim Bottomley	89
Red Ruffing	86
Red Faber	83
Luke Appling	72
Kiki Cuyler	72
Hack Wilson	72
Tony Lazzeri	59
Lefty Gomez	51
Johnny Mize	45
Lefty O'Doul	45
Earle Combs	43
Hank Gowdy	38
Joe Medwick	38
Chuck Klein	37
Marty Marion	37
Lou Boudreau	35
Bucky Harris	31
Johnny Vander Meer	31
Dave Bancroft	30
Goose Goslin	30
Chick Hafey	29
Waite Hoyt	29
Pepper Martin	29
Jimmy Dykes	27
Al Lopez	26
Allie Reynolds	24
Joe Sewell	23
Lloyd Waner	22
Jesse Haines	20
Heinie Manush	20
Bucky Walters	19
Nick Altrock	18
Glenn Wright	18
Bobby Doerr	15
Joe Judge	15
Freddie Fitzsimmons	13
Charlie Grimm	13
Howard Ehmke	12
Mel Harder	12
Eddie Rommel	12
Earl Averill	11
Joe Gordon	11
Travis Jackson	11
Wally Schang	11
Hal Schumacher	11
Cy Williams	11
Leo Durocher	10
Tommy Henrich	10
Bob Meusel	10
Red Rolfe	10
Arky Vaughan	10
Muddy Ruel	9
Frankie Crosetti	8
Paul Derringer	8
Joe Dugan	8
Wes Ferrell	8
Pete Reiser	8
Harry Brecheen	7
Orval Grove	7
Babe Herman	7
Charlie Keller	7
Terry Moore	7
Lefty Grove	6
Stan Hack	6
Freddy Lindstrom	6
Ernie Lombardi	6
Bing Miller	6
Bobo Newsom	6
Jimmie Wilson	6
Moe Berg	5
Max Bishop	5
George Kelly	5
Tommy Bridges	4
Dom DiMaggio	4
Dolf Luque	4
Riggs Stephenson	4
George Uhle	4
Lon Warneke	4
Hal White	4
Ossie Bluege	3
Dolph Camilli	3
Lew Fonseca	3
Pinky Higgins	3
Ralph Kiner	3
Red Kress	3
Bob O'Farrell	3
Schoolboy Rowe	3
Luke Sewell	3
Eddie Stanky	3
Earl Whitehill	3
Hank Edwards	2
Bob Elliott	2
Mike Gonzalez	2
Bill Hallahan	2
Tommy Holmes	2
Cookie Lavagetto	2
Dutch Leonard	2
Firpo Marberry	2
Marty McManus	2
Van Lingo Mungo	2
Jack Quinn	2
Charlie Root	2
Bill Sherdel	2
Sparky Adams	1
Dick Bartell	1
Ray Blades	1
George Case	1
Mort Cooper	1
Doc Cramer	1
Alvin Crowder	1
Harry Danning	1
Rick Ferrell	1
Heinie Groh	1
Mule Haas	1
Bubbles Hargrave	1
Addie Joss	1
Willie Kamm	1
Ken Keltner	1
Freddy Leach	1
Hans Lobert	1
Wally Moses	1
Bill Nicholson	1
Charley O'Leary	1
Johnny Pesky	1
Preacher Roe	1
Sibby Sisti	1
Gus Suhr	1
Birdie Tebbetts	1
Rube Walberg	1
Tom Zachary	1