2021 Hall of Fame Election

From BR Bullpen

The results of the 2021 Hall of Fame Election were announced on January 26, 2021. For only the fourth time since the BBWAA moved to a single ballot with no run-off in 1968, no one gained election through the writers' ballot. In addition, the Veterans Committee did not meet due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, meaning that it was the first year without a new Hall of Famer since 1960

BBWAA Voting[edit]

Eligible members of the Baseball Writers Association of America voted on a ballot comprising holdover candidates from the 2020 Hall of Fame Election and players who played their last major league game in 2015. The ballot, made public on November 16, 2020, included 25 names. In contrast to past years, there were no slam-dunk names among candidates eligible for the first time, giving an opportunity for some returning players to move forward. However, for a variety of reasons, no one was able to reach the magic 75% threshold. A total of 401 ballots were submitted, with 301 votes needed to gain election.

Coming closest were three players who had already spent a number of years on the ballot: Curt Schilling (71.1%), Barry Bonds (61.8%) and Roger Clemens (61.6%). All three made gains compared to 2020, but of 1% or less, as in all cases a large block of voters remained opposed to their candidacy due to off-field factors: the taint of steroids in Bonds and Clemens' case, and a history of hateful pronouncements in that of Schilling. Indeed, in a typical fit of pique, Schilling asked that his name be taken off the ballot for the 2022 Hall of Fame Election, a request that was unlikely to be heeded. Also of note, Omar Vizquel, who finished fifth with 49.1% and had been talked about as someone who could possibly gain from the lack of outstanding new names on the ballot, actually lost some support following allegations of domestic violence that surfaced.

Some players did make significant gains, including Scott Rolen, Billy Wagner and Todd Helton, and Gary Sheffield further down the ballot, establishing themselves as serious candidates in future years. Among the first-year eligible players, Mark Buehrle had the best score with 11%, followed by Torii Hunter at 9.5%.

Player Votes Percentage Year on the Ballot Result
Curt Schilling 285 71.1 9th
Barry Bonds 248 61.8 9th
Roger Clemens 247 61.6 9th
Scott Rolen 212 52.9 4th
Omar Vizquel 197 49.1 4th
Billy Wagner 186 46.4 6th
Todd Helton 180 44.9 3rd
Gary Sheffield 163 40.6 7th
Andruw Jones 136 33.9 4th
Jeff Kent 130 32.4 8th
Manny Ramirez 113 28.2 5th
Sammy Sosa 68 17.0 9th
Andy Pettitte 55 13.7 3rd
Mark Buehrle 44 11.0 1st
Torii Hunter 38 9.5 1st
Bobby Abreu 35 8.7 2nd
Tim Hudson 21 5.2 1st
Aramis Ramirez 4 1.0 1st Dropped
LaTroy Hawkins 2 0.5 1st Dropped
Barry Zito 1 0.2 1st Dropped
A.J. Burnett 0 0.0 1st Dropped
Michael Cuddyer 0 0.0 1st Dropped
Dan Haren 0 0.0 1st Dropped
Nick Swisher 0 0.0 1st Dropped
Shane Victorino 0 0.0 1st Dropped

Veterans Committee[edit]

The Veterans Committee decided to postpone their vote by a year because of the Coronavirus pandemic.

Induction[edit]

The induction ceremony is scheduled to take place on July 25, 2021, in Cooperstown, NY. If it takes place, it will only include the four men elected in 2020 - Derek Jeter, Larry Walker, Ted Simmons and Marvin Miller - as the previous year's induction ceremony had to be cancelled. The recipients of the Ford Frick Award for broadcasting and the J.G. Taylor Spink Award for baseball writing for 2020 and 2021 will also be honored during that week-end.

Other Awards[edit]

Al Michaels, the lead baseball broadcaster for the ABC network in the late 1970s and early 1980s, was named the winner of the Ford Frick Award for excellence in broadcasting. Dick Kaegel, who covered the St. Louis Cardinals and Kansas City Royals and was managing editor of The Sporting News, was named the winner of the J.G. Taylor Spink Award for baseball writing.

Further Reading[edit]

  • Scott Boeck: "Baseball Hall of Fame ballot 2021: No obvious choice for first-timer to be enshrined", USA Today, November 16, 2020. [1]
  • Anthony Castrovince: "Hall of Fame releases 2021 ballot", mlb.com, November 16, 2020. [2]
  • Anthony Castrovince: "No new Hall electees in rare outcome", mlb.com, January 26, 2021. [3]
  • Matt Kelly: "5 HOF candidates who deserve longer looks in '21: As ballot clears, opportunities arise for BBWAA holdovers", mlb.com, January 22, 2020. [4]
  • Bob Nightengale: "Why I voted for LaTroy Hawkins on my Baseball Hall of Fame ballot", USA Today, January 25, 2021. [5]
  • Andrew Simon: "What's next? Top storylines for '21 HOF ballot", mlb.com, January 21, 2020. [6]
  • Andrew Simon: "A hat tip to the '21 Hall ballot one-and-dones", mlb.com, January 26, 2021. [7]
  • Jesse Yomtov: "2021 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot: Mark Buehrle, Tim Hudson among the top newcomers", USA Today, January 21, 2020. [8]

Related Sites[edit]