Wild Card

From BR Bullpen

A Wild Card team is a team that qualifies for the postseason without finishing first in its division. When it was first introduced in 1994, the single Wild Card slot in each league went to the team with the best winning percentage which was not one of the three division winners. The wild card team played against the team with the best record in its league in the Division Series, if it was not a team from its own division. In that case, the wild card team played against the division winner with the second-best record. This changed in 2012.

Starting with the 2012 season, Major League Baseball and the Major League Players Association agreed to expand the wild card format to include two wild card teams in each league. The two teams played one game, the "Wild Card Game" to determine which of the two would play the division winner with the best overall record in the Division Series. As a result of the expansion of the format, the rule which prevented two teams from the same division from meeting in the Division Series was set aside. The new format was initially agreed for the 2013 season, but subsequent discussions allowed it to apply immediately in 2012. The purpose of the expansion was not only to provide one more team in each league with a berth in the postseason, but also to make the act of winning a division title more meaningful by giving non-winners an extra hurdle to clear.

In 2020, due to the shortened schedule caused by the Coronavirus pandemic, more playoff teams were added, as the second-place teams in each of the six divisions were guaranteed a postseason berth. But there remained two wild card teams in each league - the two teams with the best records among those not already guaranteed a postseason berth. This meant that instead of a Wild Card Game, each team that qualified for the postseason would play a "Wild Card Series", with the three division winners and the holder of the next best record in each league, having the advantage of being the home team for all three games of the series.

There was another change of format in 2022. One wild card team was added in each league, to make three, and the Wild Card Game was dropped. Instead, the third-ranked division winner and the three wild card teams meet in the Wild Card Series, played entirely in the home ballpark of the third division winner and the top-ranked wild card team. The winners of the two series then go on to meet one of the top two division series, who have received a bye for that round.

The Wild Card was first used in 1995; it was scheduled to be used in 1994, but the postseason was cancelled as a result of the 1994 strike. The 1981 Postseason also included an additional round of series as a result of the 1981 strike, but there was no wild card involved that year. The first wild card team to win a World Series was the Florida Marlins in 1997. There have been two World Series matching two wild card teams, in 2002 and 2014.

American League Wild Card[edit]

Note: the concept of one wild card team per league is no longer relevant following the changes to the postseason format introduced in 2022, as more than one wild card team can advance to the Division Series, which was not possible under previous formats.

Year Champion Record Manager Postseason Notes
1995 New York Yankees 79-65 Buck Showalter Lost ALDS to Seattle Mariners
1996 Baltimore Orioles 88-74 Davey Johnson Lost ALCS to New York Yankees
1997 New York Yankees 96-66 Joe Torre Lost ALDS to Cleveland Indians
1998 Boston Red Sox 92-70 Jimy Williams Lost ALDS to Cleveland Indians
1999 Boston Red Sox 94-68 Jimy Williams Lost ALCS to New York Yankees
2000 Seattle Mariners 91-71 Lou Piniella Lost ALCS to New York Yankees
2001 Oakland Athletics 102-60 Art Howe Lost ALDS to New York Yankees
2002 Anaheim Angels 99-63 Mike Scioscia Won World Series over San Francisco Giants
2003 Boston Red Sox 95-67 Grady Little Lost ALCS to New York Yankees
2004 Boston Red Sox 98-64 Terry Francona Won World Series over St. Louis Cardinals
2005 Boston Red Sox 95-67 Terry Francona Lost ALDS to Chicago White Sox 1
2006 Detroit Tigers 95-67 Jim Leyland Lost World Series to St. Louis Cardinals
2007 New York Yankees 94-68 Joe Torre Lost ALDS to Cleveland Indians
2008 Boston Red Sox 95-67 Terry Francona Lost ALCS to Tampa Bay Rays
2009 Boston Red Sox 95-67 Terry Francona Lost ALDS to Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim
2010 New York Yankees 95-67 Joe Girardi Lost ALCS to Texas Rangers
2011 Tampa Bay Rays 91-71 Joe Maddon Lost ALDS to Texas Rangers
2012 Baltimore Orioles 93-69 Buck Showalter Lost ALDS to New York Yankees
2013 Tampa Bay Rays 92-71 Joe Maddon Lost ALDS to Boston Red Sox
2014 Kansas City Royals 89-73 Ned Yost Lost World Series to San Francisco Giants
2015 Houston Astros 86-76 A.J. Hinch Lost ALDS to Kansas City Royals
2016 Toronto Blue Jays 89-73 John Gibbons Lost ALCS to Cleveland Indians
2017 New York Yankees 91-71 Joe Girardi Lost ALCS to Houston Astros
2018 New York Yankees 100-62 Aaron Boone Lost ALDS to Boston Red Sox
2019 Tampa Bay Rays 96-66 Kevin Cash Lost ALDS to Houston Astros
2021 Boston Red Sox 92-70 Alex Cora Lost ALCS to Houston Astros

Notes: Starting in 2012, the team listed is the winner of the AL Wild Card Game.

  1. The New York Yankees and Boston Red Sox finished with identical records in the AL East; Boston was named the Wild Card team because New York had a better head-to-head record.

American League Wild Card Game[edit]

Year Date Home team Record Manager Score Road team Record Manager Notes
2012 October 5 Texas Rangers 93-69 Ron Washington 1-5 Baltimore Orioles 93-69 Buck Showalter 1
2013 October 1 Cleveland Indians 92-70 Terry Francona 0-4 Tampa Bay Rays 92-71 Joe Maddon 2
2014 September 30 Kansas City Royals 89-73 Ned Yost 9-8 Oakland Athletics 88-74 Bob Melvin
2015 October 6 New York Yankees 87-75 Joe Girardi 0-3 Houston Astros 86-76 A.J. Hinch
2016 October 4 Toronto Blue Jays 89-73 John Gibbons 5-2 Baltimore Orioles 89-73 Buck Showalter 3
2017 October 3 New York Yankees 91-71 Joe Girardi 8-4 Minnesota Twins 85-77 Paul Molitor
2018 October 3 New York Yankees 100-62 Aaron Boone 7-2 Oakland Athletics 97-65 Bob Melvin
2019 October 2 Oakland Athletics 97-65 Bob Melvin 1-5 Tampa Bay Rays 96-66 Kevin Cash
2021 October 5 Boston Red Sox 92-70 Alex Cora 6-2 New York Yankees 92-70 Aaron Boone 4

Notes:

  1. The Texas Rangers won a tiebreaker for the right to host the 2012 American League Wild Card Game
  2. The Tampa Bay Rays won a one-game playoff with the Texas Rangers for the wild card spot
  3. The Toronto Blue Jays won a tiebreaker for the right to host the 2016 American League Wild Card Game
  4. The Boston Red Sox won a tiebreaker for the right to host the 2021 American League Wild Card Game

American League Wild Card Series[edit]

Year Series Home team Record Manager Score Road team Record Manager
2020 ALWC - 1 Tampa Bay Rays 40-20 Kevin Cash 2-0 Toronto Blue Jays 32-28 Charlie Montoyo
ALWC - 2 Cleveland Indians 35-25 Terry Francona 0-2 New York Yankees 33-27 Aaron Boone
ALWC - 3 Minnesota Twins 36-24 Rocco Baldelli 0-2 Houston Astros 29-31 Dusty Baker
ALWC - 4 Oakland Athletics 36-24 Bob Melvin 2-1 Chicago White Sox 35-25 Rich Renteria
2022 ALWC - 1 Cleveland Guardians 92-70 Terry Francona 2-0 Tampa Bay Rays 86-76 Kevin Cash
ALWC - 2 Toronto Blue Jays 92-70 John Schneider 0-2 Seattle Mariners 90-72 Scott Servais
2023 ALWC - 1 Minnesota Twins 87-75 Rocco Baldelli 2-0 Toronto Blue Jays 89-73 John Schneider
ALWC - 2 Tampa Bay Rays 99 - 63 Kevin Cash 0-2 Texas Rangers 90-72 Bruce Bochy

National League Wild Card[edit]

Note: the concept of one wild card team per league is no longer relevant following the changes to the postseason format introduced in 2022, as more than one wild card team can advance to the Division Series, which was not possible under previous formats.

Year Champion Record Manager Postseason Notes
1995 Colorado Rockies 77-67 Don Baylor Lost NLDS to Atlanta Braves
1996 Los Angeles Dodgers 90-72 Tommy Lasorda / Bill Russell Lost NLDS to Atlanta Braves
1997 Florida Marlins 92-70 Jim Leyland Won World Series over Cleveland Indians
1998 Chicago Cubs 90-73 Jim Riggleman Lost NLDS to Atlanta Braves 1
1999 New York Mets 97-66 Bobby Valentine Lost NLCS to Atlanta Braves 2
2000 New York Mets 94-68 Bobby Valentine Lost World Series to New York Yankees
2001 St. Louis Cardinals 93-69 Tony LaRussa Lost NLDS to Arizona Diamondbacks 3
2002 San Francisco Giants 95-66 Dusty Baker Lost World Series to Anaheim Angels
2003 Florida Marlins 91-71 Jeff Torborg / Jack McKeon Won World Series over New York Yankees
2004 Houston Astros 92-70 Jimy Williams / Phil Garner Lost NLCS to St. Louis Cardinals
2005 Houston Astros 89-73 Phil Garner Lost World Series to Chicago White Sox
2006 Los Angeles Dodgers 88-74 Grady Little Lost NLDS to New York Mets 4
2007 Colorado Rockies 90-73 Clint Hurdle Lost World Series to Boston Red Sox 5
2008 Milwaukee Brewers 90-72 Ned Yost / Dale Sveum Lost NLDS to Philadelphia Phillies
2009 Colorado Rockies 92-70 Clint Hurdle / Jim Tracy Lost NLDS to Philadelphia Phillies
2010 Atlanta Braves 91-71 Bobby Cox Lost NLDS to San Francisco Giants
2011 St. Louis Cardinals 90-72 Tony LaRussa Won World Series over Texas Rangers
2012 St. Louis Cardinals 88-74 Mike Matheny Lost NLCS to San Francisco Giants
2013 Pittsburgh Pirates 94-68 Clint Hurdle Lost NLDS to St. Louis Cardinals
2014 San Francisco Giants 88-74 Bruce Bochy Won World Series over Kansas City Royals
2015 Chicago Cubs 97-65 Joe Maddon Lost NLCS to New York Mets
2016 San Francisco Giants 87-75 Bruce Bochy Lost NLDS to Chicago Cubs
2017 Arizona Diamondbacks 93-69 Torey Lovullo Lost NLDS to Los Angeles Dodgers
2018 Colorado Rockies 91-72 Bud Black Lost NLDS to Milwaukee Brewers
2019 Washington Nationals 93-69 Dave Martinez Won World Series over Houston Astros
2021 Los Angeles Dodgers 106-56 Dave Roberts Lost NLCS to Atlanta Braves

Notes: Starting in 2012, the team listed is the winner of the NL Wild Card Game.

  1. The Chicago Cubs won a one-game playoff with the San Francisco Giants for the Wild Card slot.
  2. The New York Mets won a one-game playoff with the Cincinnati Reds for the Wild Card slot.
  3. The Houston Astros and St. Louis Cardinals finished with identical records in the NL Central; St. Louis was named the Wild Card team because Houston had a better head-to-head record.
  4. The San Diego Padres and Los Angeles Dodgers finished with identical records in the NL West; Los Angeles was named the Wild Card team because San Diego had a better head-to-head record.
  5. The Colorado Rockies won a one-game playoff with the San Diego Padres for the Wild Card slot.

National League Wild Card Game[edit]

Year Date Home team Record Manager Score Road team Record Manager Notes
2012 October 5 Atlanta Braves 94-68 Fredi Gonzalez 3-6 St. Louis Cardinals 88-74 Mike Matheny
2013 October 1 Pittsburgh Pirates 94-68 Clint Hurdle 6-2 Cincinnati Reds 90-72 Dusty Baker
2014 October 1 Pittsburgh Pirates 88-74 Clint Hurdle 0-8 San Francisco Giants 88-74 Bruce Bochy 1
2015 October 7 Pittsburgh Pirates 98-64 Clint Hurdle 0-4 Chicago Cubs 97-65 Joe Maddon
2016 October 5 New York Mets 87-75 Terry Collins 0-3 San Francisco Giants 87-75 Bruce Bochy 2
2017 October 4 Arizona Diamondbacks 93-69 Torey Lovullo 11-8 Colorado Rockies 87-75 Bud Black
2018 October 2 Chicago Cubs 95-68 Joe Maddon 1-2 Colorado Rockies 91-72 Bud Black
2019 October 1 Washington Nationals 93-69 Dave Martinez 4-3 Milwaukee Brewers 89-73 Craig Counsell
2021 October 6 Los Angeles Dodgers 106-56 Dave Roberts 3-1 St. Louis Cardinals 90-72 Mike Shildt

Notes:

  1. The Pittsburgh Pirates won a tiebreaker for the right to host the 2014 National League Wild Card Game
  2. The New York Mets won a tiebreaker for the right to host the 2016 National League Wild Card Game

National League Wild Card Series[edit]

Year Series Home team Record Manager Score Road team Record Manager
2020 NLWC - 1 Los Angeles Dodgers 43-17 Dave Roberts 2-0 Milwaukee Brewers 29-31 Craig Counsell
NLWC - 2 San Diego Padres 37-23 Jayce Tingler 2-1 St. Louis Cardinals 30-28 Mike Shildt
NLWC - 3 Chicago Cubs 34-26 David Ross 0-2 Miami Marlins 31-29 Don Mattingly
NLWC - 4 Atlanta Braves 35-25 Brian Snitker 2-0 Cincinnati Reds 31-29 David Bell
2022 NLWC - 1 St. Louis Cardinals 93-69 Oliver Marmol 0-2 Philadelphia Phillies 87-75 Rob Thomson
NLWC - 2 New York Mets 101-61 Buck Showalter 1-2 San Diego Padres 89-73 Bob Melvin
2023 NLWC - 1 Milwaukee Brewers 92-70 Craig Counsell 0-2 Arizona Diamondbacks 84-78 Torey Lovullo
NLWC - 2 Philadelphia Phillies 90-72 Rob Thomson 2-0 Miami Marlins 84-78 Skip Schumaker


Major League Baseball Wild Card Game

National League
2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019
2021
American League
2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019
2021

Major League Baseball Wild Card Series

National League
2020-1 | 2020-2 | 2020-3 | 2020-4 | 2022-1 | 2022-2 | 2023-1 | 2023-2
American League
2020-1 | 2020-2 | 2020-3 | 2020-4 | 2022-1 | 2022-2 | 2023-1 | 2023-2