Rankings of Negro League players should consider that Negro League data is not complete. Research is still ongoing and we’ll continue to publish updates as more information becomes available. More about data coverage

Major League Pitching Leaders

Wins Above Replacement--all
1. MusialSTL 11.3
2. BoudreauCLE 10.4
3. SainBSN 8.6
4. BrecheenSTL 8.5
5. WilliamsBOS 8.3
6. DiMaggioNYY 6.9
7. NewhouserDET 6.7
8. MizeNYG 6.6
9. GordonCLE 6.5
10. LemonCLE 6.4
WAR for Pitchers
1. BrecheenSTL 8.7
2. SainBSN 8.5
3. NewhouserDET 6.5
4. LeonardPHI 6.3
5. Vander MeerCIN 5.5
6. SchmitzCHC 5.4
7. ScarboroughWSH 5.2
8. GarverSLB 4.9
9. RoeBRO 4.9
10. LemonCLE 4.7
WilksSTL 4.7
Earned Run Average
1. RicksPS 1.56
2. ManningNE 1.59
3. ByrdBEG 1.68
4. LewisNE 1.86
5. BlackBEG 1.91
6. RombyBEG 2.10
7. BrecheenSTL 2.24
8. BrownPS 2.38
9. SmithKCM 2.43
10. BeardenCLE 2.43
Wins
1. SainBSN 24
2. NewhouserDET 21
3. BeardenCLE 20
LemonCLE 20
BrecheenSTL 20
6. FellerCLE 19
RaschiNYY 19
8. KramerBOS 18
JansenNYG 18
SchmitzCHC 18
Win-Loss %
1. RicksPS 1.000
2. FieldsHG .857
3. PowellBBB .833
4. SewellPIT .813
5. KramerBOS .783
6. JohnsonKCM .750
NewberryBBB .750
ParkerHG .750
9. BeardenCLE .741
BrecheenSTL .741
Walks & Hits per IP
1. ByrdBEG 1.022
2. BrecheenSTL 1.037
3. BlackBEG 1.041
4. RoeBRO 1.064
5. HookerNE 1.087
6. ManningNE 1.112
7. LewisNE 1.112
8. SmithKCM 1.114
9. RombyBEG 1.167
10. SchmitzCHC 1.169
Hits per 9 IP
1. CollinsKCM 5.304
2. RombyBEG 6.400
3. BlackBEG 6.512
4. LewisNE 6.517
5. ParkerHG 6.659
6. SheaNYY 6.764
7. SchmitzCHC 6.917
8. ManningNE 6.988
9. BarneyBRO 7.042
10. LemonCLE 7.079
Bases On Balls per 9 IP
1. ScantleburyNYC 1.543
2. ByrdBEG 1.605
3. HookerNE 1.630
4. BurkeBEG 1.645
5. RoeBRO 1.672
6. JansenNYG 1.755
7. LaMarqueKCM 1.831
8. RaffensbergerCIN 1.847
9. NewberryBBB 1.851
10. BrecheenSTL 1.890
Strikeouts per 9 IP
1. CollinsKCM 9.964
2. RichardsonKCM 7.455
3. BrownPS 6.988
4. PowellBBB 6.968
5. RombyBEG 6.800
6. BlackBEG 6.750
7. SmithKCM 6.629
8. StewartCAG 6.568
9. GreasonBBB 6.557
10. CatheyIC 6.467
Games Played
1. GumbertCIN 61
2. WilksSTL 57
3. HigbePIT 56
4. PageNYY 55
JonesNYG 55
6. DobernicCHC 54
7. TrinkleNYG 53
8. WidmarSLB 49
9. BiscanSLB 47
10. ThompsonWSH 46
Saves
1. ChristopherCLE 17
GumbertCIN 17
3. PageNYY 16
4. WilksSTL 13
5. FerrickWSH 10
HouttemanDET 10
HigbePIT 10
8. JudsonCHW 8
9. BehrmanBRO 7
TrinkleNYG 7
Innings Pitched
1. SainBSN 314.2
2. LemonCLE 293.2
3. FellerCLE 280.1
4. JansenNYG 277.0
5. NewhouserDET 272.1
6. SpahnBSN 257.0
7. DicksonSTL 252.1
8. BarneyBRO 246.2
9. DobsonBOS 245.1
10. SchmitzCHC 242.0
Strikeouts
1. FellerCLE 164
2. BrecheenSTL 149
3. LemonCLE 147
4. NewhouserDET 143
5. BarneyBRO 138
6. SainBSN 137
7. BrissiePHA 127
8. JansenNYG 126
9. RaschiNYY 124
10. TrucksDET 123
Games Started
1. SainBSN 39
2. FellerCLE 38
3. LemonCLE 37
4. JansenNYG 36
5. NewhouserDET 35
SpahnBSN 35
7. BarneyBRO 34
8. SanfordSLB 33
Vander MeerCIN 33
10. DobsonBOS 32
WightCHW 32
Complete Games
1. SainBSN 28
2. BrecheenSTL 21
3. LemonCLE 20
4. NewhouserDET 19
5. FellerCLE 18
RaschiNYY 18
SchmitzCHC 18
8. DobsonBOS 16
FowlerPHA 16
ParnellBOS 16
LeonardPHI 16
SpahnBSN 16
Shutouts
1. LemonCLE 10
2. BrecheenSTL 7
3. BeardenCLE 6
RaschiNYY 6
5. DobsonBOS 5
6. RaffensbergerCIN 4
SainBSN 4
BarneyBRO 4
JansenNYG 4
10. SheaNYY 3
RiddlePIT 3
PoatNYG 3
MeyerCHC 3
SpahnBSN 3
KosloNYG 3
Vander MeerCIN 3
LewisNE 3
ColemanPHA 3
FanninSLB 3
LopatNYY 3
Home Runs
1. DicksonSTL 39
2. HutchinsonDET 32
3. JansenNYG 25
4. BrancaBRO 24
5. PoatNYG 22
6. WehmeierCIN 21
7. FellerCLE 20
8. MarchildonPHA 19
SanfordSLB 19
SainBSN 19
SpahnBSN 19
Bases on Balls
1. WightCHW 135
2. MarchildonPHA 131
3. LemonCLE 129
4. Vander MeerCIN 124
5. MastersonWSH 122
BarneyBRO 122
7. Kennedy2TM 117
8. FellerCLE 116
9. ReynoldsNYY 111
10. SimmonsPHI 108
Hits
1. SainBSN 297
2. JansenNYG 283
3. DicksonSTL 257
4. FellerCLE 255
5. SanfordSLB 250
6. NewhouserDET 249
7. LopatNYY 246
8. ReynoldsNYY 240
9. WightCHW 238
10. DobsonBOS 237
SpahnBSN 237
Strikeouts / Base On Balls
1. ByrdBEG 3.591
2. LaMarqueKCM 3.333
3. SmithKCM 3.154
4. ScantleburyNYC 3.150
5. BrecheenSTL 3.041
6. BrownPS 2.750
NewberryBBB 2.750
8. CatheyIC 2.667
9. RoeBRO 2.606
10. HookerNE 2.563
Home Runs per 9 IP
1. BrewerCBE 0.000
BurkeBEG 0.000
StewartCAG 0.000
ManningNE 0.000
SmithKCM 0.000
CollinsKCM 0.000
GreasonBBB 0.000
RicksPS 0.000
9. RombyBEG 0.100
10. GainesBEG 0.108
Losses
1. SanfordSLB 21
2. WightCHW 20
3. WynnWSH 19
4. LeonardPHI 17
5. HouttemanDET 16
HudsonWSH 16
DicksonSTL 16
8. FellerCLE 15
MarchildonPHA 15
MastersonWSH 15
PetersonCIN 15
SainBSN 15
Earned Runs
1. WynnWSH 128
2. HudsonWSH 119
WightCHW 119
4. SanfordSLB 117
5. DicksonSTL 116
6. MarchildonPHA 114
7. FellerCLE 111
JansenNYG 111
9. HutchinsonDET 106
SpahnBSN 106
Wild Pitches
1. JonesNYG 10
2. ReynoldsNYY 9
BrancaBRO 9
RiddlePIT 9
SingletonPIT 9
6. BrissiePHA 7
MarchildonPHA 7
StephensSLB 7
TrucksDET 7
10. BiscanSLB 6
ColemanPHA 6
DobsonBOS 6
WidmarSLB 6
ChesnesPIT 6
SchmitzCHC 6
SimmonsPHI 6
Hit By Pitch
1. BiscanSLB 9
ByrneNYY 9
3. LaMarqueKCM 8
4. FerrissBOS 7
5. GromekCLE 6
HaefnerWSH 6
HudsonWSH 6
ClarkeCBE 6
BarneyBRO 6
JonesNYG 6
PetersonCIN 6
Harrist2TM 6
Batters Faced
1. SainBSN 1,313
2. LemonCLE 1,214
3. FellerCLE 1,186
4. NewhouserDET 1,146
5. JansenNYG 1,137
6. DicksonSTL 1,064
SpahnBSN 1,064
8. DobsonBOS 1,044
9. BarneyBRO 1,028
10. ReynoldsNYY 1,017
Games Finished
1. GumbertCIN 46
2. PageNYY 38
3. HigbePIT 31
TrinkleNYG 31
5. ChristopherCLE 28
6. DobernicCHC 27
WilksSTL 27
8. FerrickWSH 26
9. ThompsonWSH 24
10. BiscanSLB 22
Adjusted ERA+
1. RicksPS 218
2. ManningNE 213
3. ByrdBEG 201
4. SmithKCM 198
5. NewberryBBB 183
6. BrecheenSTL 182
7. LewisNE 182
8. BlackBEG 177
9. PowellBBB 172
10. BeardenCLE 168
Fielding Independent Pitching
1. ByrdBEG 2.24
2. SmithKCM 2.25
3. GainesBEG 2.47
4. BrecheenSTL 2.47
5. NewberryBBB 2.51
6. ManningNE 2.52
7. RichardsonKCM 2.53
8. LaMarqueKCM 2.54
9. BlackBEG 2.58
10. BrewerCBE 2.70
Adj. Pitching Runs
1. BrecheenSTL 48
2. SainBSN 45
3. BeardenCLE 43
4. LemonCLE 43
5. NewhouserDET 37
6. LeonardPHI 30
7. SchmitzCHC 29
8. ScarboroughWSH 28
9. ParnellBOS 27
10. RoeBRO 26
Adj. Pitching Wins
1. BrecheenSTL 5.3
2. SainBSN 4.8
3. BeardenCLE 4.4
4. LemonCLE 4.4
5. NewhouserDET 3.8
6. LeonardPHI 3.1
7. SchmitzCHC 3.1
8. ScarboroughWSH 2.9
9. RoeBRO 2.8
10. ParnellBOS 2.7
Base-Out Runs Saved (RE24)
1. LemonCLE 53.69
2. BeardenCLE 51.39
3. SainBSN 50.24
4. BrecheenSTL 49.04
5. RoeBRO 31.78
6. BarneyBRO 27.58
7. ScarboroughWSH 27.51
8. GromekCLE 25.12
9. FellerCLE 24.73
10. SchmitzCHC 24.17
Win Probability Added (WPA)
1. BrecheenSTL 5.2
2. SainBSN 5.0
3. BeardenCLE 4.6
4. RoeBRO 4.2
5. ScarboroughWSH 3.2
6. SpahnBSN 3.2
7. SchmitzCHC 3.1
8. NewhouserDET 2.9
9. Potter3TM 2.8
10. FellerCLE 2.7
Sit. Wins Saved (WPA/LI)
1. LemonCLE 5.5
2. BrecheenSTL 4.9
3. FellerCLE 3.7
4. SainBSN 3.7
5. BeardenCLE 3.0
6. SchmitzCHC 2.9
7. BarneyBRO 2.8
8. RoeBRO 2.8
9. NewhouserDET 2.4
10. JansenNYG 2.3
Championship WPA (cWPA)
1. BeardenCLE 29.4
2. SpahnBSN 22.5
3. SainBSN 18.0
4. FellerCLE 11.5
5. GromekCLE 9.7
6. Potter3TM 8.0
7. Zoldak2TM 7.6
8. BrecheenSTL 7.3
9. HattenBRO 7.1
10. BarneyBRO 6.5
Base-Out Wins Saved (REW)
1. LemonCLE 5.8
2. BeardenCLE 5.6
3. SainBSN 5.5
4. BrecheenSTL 5.3
5. RoeBRO 3.3
6. BarneyBRO 2.8
7. ScarboroughWSH 2.8
8. GromekCLE 2.6
9. SchmitzCHC 2.5
10. FellerCLE 2.5