Site Maintenance is scheduled for Wednesday July 24th. The Bullpen will be set to read-only during this time. More updates to follow on the 24th.

Intentional walk

From BR Bullpen

(Redirected from Intentional Base-on-Balls)

An intentional walk (aka intentional base on balls or IBB) is a walk issued when a pitcher deliberately throws completely unhittable pitches in order to have the batter advance to first base.

According to Peter Morris's A Game of Inches, the first known instance of an intentional walk was discovered by researcher Greg Rhodes. It occurred on June 27, 1870, in a game between the Cincinnati Red Stockings and the Olympics of Washington: "The pitcher of the Olympics did his best to let George Wright take his first every time on called balls, as he preferred that to George's style of hitting. George went to first twice on called balls, but on three or four other occasions he managed to strike the ball."

A walk is only considered intentional if the catcher gives a clear sign that he is calling for an unhittable ball. Normally he does this by standing up instead of crouching and reaching one hand outside. The pitcher then throws the ball toward the catcher's hand, and the catcher steps over to catch the ball. The catcher must be careful not to step over to catch the pitch until after the pitcher has thrown; stepping out of his box prematurely will result in a balk. If a pitcher throws only unhittable pitches without a prior signal, in the hope that the hitter will take the bait and swing on a bad pitch outside the strike zone, it is not counted as an intentional walk but as a regular base on balls.

For decades, the pitcher had to actually go through the motions of throwing four pitches outside of the strike zone; he could not simply indicate that he was conceding the base to the batter. This distinction was not normally important, but on rare occasions the pitcher would accidentally throw a hittable pitch that the batter swung at, or a wild pitch. However, in 2014, Major League Baseball introduced the "automatic intentional walk" on a test basis in the Arizona Fall League, as part of a set of measures to speed up the flow of the game; in this scenario, the manager signaled the home plate umpire by showing four fingers, after which the batter automatically moved to first base without the need to throw any pitches. In 2017, Major League Baseball adopted a variation of this rule through which the defensive team's manager simply had to signal his intention to the home plate umpire to walk the batter intentionally in order for the batter to proceed directly to first base, without the need to make any pitches. This was nominally done to speed up the game, although observers pointed out that intentional walks were so few, and were usually dispatched so quickly, that the gain in time would be microscopic. The first time the new rule was used came on April 2nd, when Chicago Cubs manager Joe Maddon called on Mike Montgomery to walk Yadier Molina of the St. Louis Cardinals in the 9th inning.

One of the side effects of the rule change was that it caused managers and front offices to re-examine the use of the intentional walk as a strategy. Its frequency had already gone down significantly in recent decades, and the trend was only accelerating: for example, the 2019 Houston Astros did not issue a single intentional walk during the entire season! That was coming after a season in which they had issued only 4 in 2018. This was the result of the team's analysis showing that any short-term advantage gained by issuing a free pass was more than negated by the extra baserunner and the additional plate appearances to opposition batters in almost all situations.

Intentional walks are normally issued for two reasons: to bypass a good hitter for a weaker one or one who does not have the platoon advantage; and/or to set up a double play. The usefulness of intentional walks for either reason is a matter of considerable debate, and different managers have taken very different attitudes toward the intentional walk. Walter Alston even changed his approach in mid-career, moving from issuing 101 (the 8th most ever) in 1967 to just 9 (the fewest ever at the time) in 1974.

Before Barry Bonds broke the single-season record with 68 in 2002, and then increased it to the current mark of 120 two years later, it was held by Willie McCovey, with the relatively paltry total of 45.

It should be noted that statistics concerning intentional walks have only been kept separately since 1955.

All Time Leaders
Span Player Total Notes
Career Barry Bonds 688
Season Barry Bonds 120 2004
Game Andre Dawson 5 16-inning game, May 22, 1990
Game Barry Bonds 4 9-inning game, May 1, 2004
Game Barry Bonds 4 9-inning game, September 22, 2004

Intentional walk with the bases loaded[edit]

Player Date League Team Opponent Inning
Abner Dalrymple August 2, 1881 National League Chicago Buffalo 8th
Nap Lajoie May 23, 1901 American League Philadelphia Chicago 9th
Del Bissonette May 2, 1928 National League Brooklyn New York 9th
Bill Nicholson July 23, 1944 National League Chicago New York 8th
Barry Bonds May 28, 1998 National League San Francisco Arizona 9th
Josh Hamilton August 17, 2008 American League Texas Tampa Bay 9th

Further Reading[edit]

  • Associated Press: "Astros set MLB record with zero intentional walks in 2019", USA Today, October 4, 2019. [1]
  • Ted Berg: "Long live the four-pitch intentional walk!", "For the Win!", USA Today Sports, February 22, 2017. [2]
  • Bill Deane: "Surprise Swings at Intentional Balls", in The Baseball Research Journal, SABR, Volume 40, Number 1 (Spring 2011), pp. 108-109.
  • Mike Petriello: "Say farewell to the intentional walk: Astros on pace to become first team to issue 0 free passes",, July 10, 2019. [3]
  • Joe Posnanski: "Anticipated rule could continue decline of IBB",, February 22, 2017. [4]
  • Joe Posnanski: "10 questions about new intentional walk rule",, March 3, 2017. [5]