1950s Topps All-Star cards

Starting in 1958, Topps issued in its sets of baseball cards a subset depicting the players who had been selected as the "All-Star player" at their respective position during the previous year. This would sometimes be interpreted as the player who was selected to start the previous year's All-Star Game, or had been named as part of a post-season All-Star team selected by a respected source such as Sport Magazine or The Sporting News.

1958 Topps

This subset was the final 21 cards of the set, including a single card for the two managers and the first ever Topps card featuring Stan Musial. The selections were sponsored by Sport Magazine.

• 475 Casey Stengel/Fred Haney Managers

American League

• 477 Bill Skowron Yankees 1B
• 479 Nellie Fox White Sox 2B
• 481 Frank Malzone Red Sox 3B
• 483 Luis Aparicio White Sox SS
• 485 Ted Williams Red Sox OF
• 487 Mickey Mantle Yankees OF
• 489 Jackie Jensen Red Sox OF
• 491 Sherm Lollar White Sox C
• 493 Bob Turley Yankees RHP
• 495 Herb Score Indians LHP

National League

• 476 Stan Musial Cardinals 1B
• 478 Johnny Temple Reds 2B
• 480 Eddie Mathews Braves 3B
• 482 Ernie Banks Cubs SS
• 484 Frank Robinson Reds OF
• 486 Willie Mays Giants OF
• 488 Hank Aaron Braves OF
• 490 Ed Bailey Reds C
• 492 Bob Friend Pirates RHP
• 494 Warren Spahn Braves LHP

1959 Topps

This 22-card subset was sponsored by The Sporting News.

American League

• 552 Casey Stengel Yankees MGR
• 554 Bill Skowron Yankees 1B
• 556 Nellie Fox White Sox 2B
• 558 Frank Malzone Red Sox 3B
• 560 Luis Aparicio White Sox SS
• 562 Al Kaline Tigers OF
• 564 Mickey Mantle Yankees OF
• 566 Roy Sievers Senators OF
• 568 Gus Triandos Orioles OF
• 570 Bob Turley Yankees OF
• 572 Billy Pierce White Sox OF

National League

• 551 Fred Haney Braves MGR
• 553 Orlando Cepeda Giants 1B
• 555 Bill Mazeroski Pirates 2B
• 557 Ken Boyer Cardinals 3B
• 559 Ernie Banks Cubs SS
• 561 Hank Aaron Braves OF
• 563 Willie Mays Giants NL OF
• 565 Wes Covington Braves OF
• 567 Del Crandall Braves OF
• 569 Bob Friend Pirates OF
• 571 Warren Spahn Braves OF