Single-Season Top 10 Leaders

WAR for Pitchers †
1. Bobby Mathews • 1874 13.6
2. Bobby Mathews • 1873 10.0
3. Candy Cummings • 1872 8.8
4. Bobby Mathews • 1875 8.3
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 3.1
6. Count Gedney • 1875 0.5
7. John Hatfield • 1874 0.1
Phonney Martin • 1873 0.1
Earned Run Average
1. Bobby Mathews • 1874 1.9
2. Bobby Mathews • 1875 2.49
3. Bobby Mathews • 1873 2.58
4. Candy Cummings • 1872 3.01
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 3.43
Wins
1. Bobby Mathews • 1874 42
2. Candy Cummings • 1872 33
3. Bobby Mathews • 1873 29
Bobby Mathews • 1875 29
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 16
6. Count Gedney • 1875 1
John McMullin • 1872 1
Win-Loss %
1. Bobby Mathews • 1874 .656
2. Candy Cummings • 1872 .623
3. Bobby Mathews • 1873 .558
4. Rynie Wolters • 1871 .500
5. Bobby Mathews • 1875 .433
Walks & Hits per IP
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 1.168
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 1.199
3. Bobby Mathews • 1873 1.244
4. Candy Cummings • 1872 1.278
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 1.357
Hits per 9 IP
1. Bobby Mathews • 1873 9.935
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 10.152
3. Bobby Mathews • 1875 10.227
4. Candy Cummings • 1872 10.938
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 10.972
Bases On Balls per 9 IP
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 0.288
2. Candy Cummings • 1872 0.561
3. Bobby Mathews • 1874 0.638
4. Rynie Wolters • 1871 1.240
5. Bobby Mathews • 1873 1.260
Strikeouts per 9 IP
1. Bobby Mathews • 1873 1.605
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 1.573
3. Bobby Mathews • 1875 1.079
4. Candy Cummings • 1872 0.815
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 0.700
Games Played
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 70
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 65
3. Candy Cummings • 1872 55
4. Bobby Mathews • 1873 52
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 32
6. Phonney Martin • 1873 6
7. John Hatfield • 1874 3
John McMullin • 1872 3
9. Count Gedney • 1875 2
10. Bob Ferguson • 1871 1
Frank Fleet • 1871 1
Saves
1. John McMullin • 1872 1
Innings Pitched
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 625.2
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 578.0
3. Candy Cummings • 1872 497.0
4. Bobby Mathews • 1873 443.0
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 283.0
6. Phonney Martin • 1873 34.0
7. John McMullin • 1872 15.0
8. Count Gedney • 1875 11.0
9. Frank Fleet • 1871 9.0
10. John Hatfield • 1874 8.0
Strikeouts
1. Bobby Mathews • 1874 101
2. Bobby Mathews • 1873 79
3. Bobby Mathews • 1875 75
4. Candy Cummings • 1872 45
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 22
6. Count Gedney • 1875 2
7. Phonney Martin • 1873 1
John McMullin • 1872 1
Games Started
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 70
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 65
3. Candy Cummings • 1872 55
4. Bobby Mathews • 1873 52
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 32
6. Frank Fleet • 1871 1
Count Gedney • 1875 1
Phonney Martin • 1873 1
John McMullin • 1872 1
Complete Games
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 69
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 62
3. Candy Cummings • 1872 53
4. Bobby Mathews • 1873 47
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 31
6. Frank Fleet • 1871 1
Count Gedney • 1875 1
Phonney Martin • 1873 1
John McMullin • 1872 1
Shutouts
1. Bobby Mathews • 1874 4
2. Candy Cummings • 1872 3
Bobby Mathews • 1875 3
4. Bobby Mathews • 1873 2
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 1
Home Runs
1. Rynie Wolters • 1871 7
2. Bobby Mathews • 1873 5
3. Bobby Mathews • 1875 4
4. Bobby Mathews • 1874 3
5. Candy Cummings • 1872 2
Bases on Balls
1. Bobby Mathews • 1873 62
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 41
3. Rynie Wolters • 1871 39
4. Candy Cummings • 1872 31
5. Bobby Mathews • 1875 20
6. Phonney Martin • 1873 6
7. Frank Fleet • 1871 3
8. John McMullin • 1872 2
9. Count Gedney • 1875 1
Hits
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 711
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 652
3. Candy Cummings • 1872 604
4. Bobby Mathews • 1873 489
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 345
6. Phonney Martin • 1873 50
7. Frank Fleet • 1871 20
8. John McMullin • 1872 18
9. John Hatfield • 1874 11
10. Bob Ferguson • 1871 8
Strikeouts / Base On Balls
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 3.75
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 2.463
3. Candy Cummings • 1872 1.452
4. Bobby Mathews • 1873 1.274
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 0.564
Home Runs per 9 IP
1. Candy Cummings • 1872 0.036
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 0.047
3. Bobby Mathews • 1875 0.058
4. Bobby Mathews • 1873 0.102
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 0.223
Losses
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 38
2. Bobby Mathews • 1873 23
3. Bobby Mathews • 1874 22
4. Candy Cummings • 1872 20
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 16
6. Frank Fleet • 1871 1
John Hatfield • 1874 1
Phonney Martin • 1873 1
Earned Runs
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 173
2. Candy Cummings • 1872 166
3. Bobby Mathews • 1873 127
4. Bobby Mathews • 1874 122
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 108
6. Phonney Martin • 1873 13
7. Frank Fleet • 1871 10
8. John McMullin • 1872 6
9. Bob Ferguson • 1871 3
10. John Hatfield • 1874 2
Wild Pitches
1. Bobby Mathews • 1874 32
2. Bobby Mathews • 1875 28
3. Bobby Mathews • 1873 23
4. Candy Cummings • 1872 15
Rynie Wolters • 1871 15
6. John McMullin • 1872 3
7. Bob Ferguson • 1871 2
Count Gedney • 1875 2
9. Phonney Martin • 1873 1
Batters Faced
1. Bobby Mathews • 1875 2759
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 2543
3. Candy Cummings • 1872 2251
4. Bobby Mathews • 1873 2008
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 1349
6. Phonney Martin • 1873 177
7. John McMullin • 1872 75
8. Frank Fleet • 1871 57
9. Count Gedney • 1875 43
10. John Hatfield • 1874 35
Games Finished
1. Phonney Martin • 1873 5
2. John Hatfield • 1874 3
3. John McMullin • 1872 2
4. Count Gedney • 1875 1
Rynie Wolters • 1871 1
Adjusted ERA+
1. Bobby Mathews • 1873 127
2. Bobby Mathews • 1874 117
3. Rynie Wolters • 1871 111
4. Candy Cummings • 1872 110
5. Bobby Mathews • 1875 90
Fielding Independent Pitching
1. Bobby Mathews • 1874 2.00
2. Bobby Mathews • 1875 2.18
3. Bobby Mathews • 1873 3.31
4. Candy Cummings • 1872 3.49
5. Rynie Wolters • 1871 4.16
Adj. Pitching Runs
1. Candy Cummings • 1872 34
2. Bobby Mathews • 1873 33
3. Bobby Mathews • 1874 27
4. Rynie Wolters • 1871 11
5. Count Gedney • 1875 2
Adj. Pitching Wins
1. Candy Cummings • 1872 2.4
Bobby Mathews • 1873 2.4
3. Bobby Mathews • 1874 2.1
4. Rynie Wolters • 1871 0.7
5. Count Gedney • 1875 0.2

Data Notes