1886 Major League Team Starting Lineups

Become a Stathead & surf this site ad-free.

1886 Most Common Starters

Players listed have the most games at that position
(WAR)

1886 Most Common Starters
Rk	Tm	C	1B	2B	3B	SS	LF	CF	RF
1	Baltimore Orioles	C.Fulmer (3.80)	M.Scott (-0.40)	M.Muldoon (0.08)	J.Davis (-0.51)	J.Macullar (0.17)	J.Sommer (-1.32)	P.O'Connell (-1.07)	J.Manning (-0.77)
2	Brooklyn	J.Peoples (0.11)	B.Phillips (1.52)	B.McClellan (2.19)	G.Pinkney (1.57)	G.Smith (1.50)	E.Burch (0.24)	J.McTamany (2.30)	E.Swartwood (2.82)
3	Boston	C.Daily (0.81)	S.Wise (2.41)	J.Burdock (-0.57)	B.Nash (2.16)	J.Morrill (2.49)	J.Hornung (0.50)	D.Johnston (-0.03)	T.Poorman (1.31)
4	Chicago White Stockings	S.Flint (-0.45)	C.Anson (6.95)	F.Pfeffer (1.76)	T.Burns (2.42)	E.Williamson (2.13)	A.Dalrymple (0.52)	G.Gore (4.50)	K.Kelly (7.29)
5	Cincinnati	K.Baldwin (0.39)	J.Reilly (0.91)	B.McPhee (4.00)	H.Carpenter (-0.81)	F.Fennelly (3.89)	C.Jones (2.20)	F.Lewis (1.46)	J.Corkhill (0.32)
6	Detroit Wolverines	C.Bennett (3.92)	D.Brouthers (8.21)	F.Dunlap (1.93)	D.White (2.74)	J.Rowe (4.21)	H.Richardson (6.90)	N.Hanlon (1.16)	S.Thompson (4.10)
7	Kansas City Cowboys	F.Briody (0.70)	M.McQuery (0.44)	A.Myers (1.13)	J.Donnelly (-1.43)	C.Bassett (1.61)	J.Lillie (-3.87)	D.Rowe (-0.91)	P.Radford (-0.05)
8	Louisville Colonels	J.Kerins (3.45)	P.Cook (-1.54)	R.Mack (2.52)	J.Werrick (0.96)	B.White (1.57)	J.Strauss (-1.44)	P.Browning (2.25)	C.Wolf (0.96)
9	New York Giants	B.Ewing (2.76)	R.Connor (7.07)	J.Gerhardt (-1.09)	D.Esterbrook (1.40)	J.Ward (2.60)	P.Gillespie (0.21)	J.O'Rourke (3.64)	M.Dorgan (1.51)
10	New York Metropolitans	C.Reipschlager (-0.49)	D.Orr (6.34)	T.Forster (-0.26)	F.Hankinson (2.43)	C.Nelson (1.04)	J.Roseman (-0.22)	S.Behel (-0.42)	S.Brady (-0.47)
11	Philadelphia Athletics	W.Robinson (-0.74)	H.Stovey (3.84)	L.Bierbauer (-0.71)	J.Gleason (-0.86)	C.McGarr (0.52)	H.Larkin (4.41)	E.Greer (-1.03)	J.Coleman (1.13)
12	Philadelphia Phillies	D.McGuire (0.33)	S.Farrar (2.08)	C.Bastian (2.34)	J.Mulvey (2.28)	A.Irwin (2.23)	G.Wood (1.82)	E.Andrews (1.62)	J.Fogarty (3.02)
13	Allegheny City	F.Carroll (3.99)	O.Schomberg (1.75)	S.Barkley (3.27)	A.Whitney (2.58)	P.Smith (3.12)	E.Glenn (-0.65)	F.Mann (1.63)	T.Brown (2.29)
14	St. Louis Maroons	G.Myers (0.05)	A.McKinnon (3.42)	F.Dunlap (2.06)	J.Denny (3.52)	J.Glasscock (7.03)	E.Seery (0.98)	J.McGeachey (-0.60)	J.Cahill (-1.36)
15	St. Louis Browns	D.Bushong (1.91)	C.Comiskey (0.57)	W.Robinson (3.57)	A.Latham (4.30)	B.Gleason (1.62)	T.O'Neill (4.89)	C.Welch (3.40)	H.Nicol (-0.23)
16	Washington Nationals	B.Gilligan (1.37)	P.Baker (0.03)	J.Knowles (0.18)	B.Gladmon (-0.70)	D.Force (0.45)	C.Carroll (0.55)	P.Hines (4.15)	E.Crane (-3.67)