Best OPS+ seasons by players weighing 175 lbs or less
Posted by Andy on December 14, 2007
Did you know that the PI includes height and weight data? For some reason, after yesterday, I was inclined to look at lighter players today. Here are the top seasons since 1977, ranked by OPS+, for players listed at 175 lbs or less, minimum 400 PA:
Cnt Player **OPS+** Wt PA Year Age Tm Lg G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB IBB SO HBP SH SF GDP SB CS BA OBP SLG OPS Positions +----+-----------------+--------+---+---+----+---+---+--+---+---+---+---+--+--+--+---+---+---+---+---+---+---+---+---+--+-----+-----+-----+-----+---------+ 1 Lonnie Smith 168 170 577 1989 33 ATL NL 134 482 89 152 34 4 21 79 76 3 95 11 1 7 7 25 12 .315 .415 .533 .948 *7 2 Magglio Ordonez 167 170 678 2007 33 DET AL 157 595 117 216 54 0 28 139 76 8 79 2 0 5 20 4 1 .363 .434 .595 1.029 *9D 3 Robin Yount 166 170 704 1982 26 MIL AL 156 635 129 210 46 12 29 114 54 2 63 1 4 10 19 14 3 .331 .379 .578 .957 *6/D 4 Sixto Lezcano 164 175 566 1979 25 MIL AL 138 473 84 152 29 3 28 101 77 5 74 3 6 7 11 4 3 .321 .414 .573 .987 *9/D7 5 Adrian Beltre 163 170 657 2004 25 LAD NL 156 598 104 200 32 0 48 121 53 9 87 2 0 4 15 7 2 .334 .388 .629 1.017 *5/6 6 Oscar Gamble 162 165 470 1977 27 CHW AL 137 408 75 121 22 2 31 83 54 2 54 6 1 1 3 1 2 .297 .386 .588 .974 *D9/87 7 Don Mattingly 161 175 742 1986 25 NYY AL 162 677 117 238 53 2 31 113 53 11 35 1 1 10 17 0 0 .352 .394 .573 .967 *3/5D 8 Don Mattingly 156 175 727 1985 24 NYY AL 159 652 107 211 48 3 35 145 56 13 41 2 2 15 15 2 2 .324 .371 .567 .938 *3 9 Don Mattingly 156 175 662 1984 23 NYY AL 153 603 91 207 44 2 23 110 41 8 33 1 8 9 15 1 1 .343 .381 .537 .918 *37/98 10 Nomar Garciaparra 155 165 599 2000 26 BOS AL 140 529 104 197 51 3 21 96 61 20 50 2 0 7 8 5 2 .372 .434 .599 1.033 *6/D 11 Alan Trammell 155 175 668 1987 29 DET AL 151 597 109 205 34 3 28 105 60 8 47 3 2 6 11 21 2 .343 .402 .551 .953 *6 12 Magglio Ordonez 153 170 653 2002 28 CHW AL 153 590 116 189 47 1 38 135 53 2 77 7 0 3 21 7 5 .320 .381 .597 .978 *9/D 13 Nomar Garciaparra 153 165 595 1999 25 BOS AL 135 532 103 190 42 4 27 104 51 7 39 8 0 4 11 14 3 .357 .418 .603 1.021 *6 14 Derek Jeter 153 175 739 1999 25 NYY AL 158 627 134 219 37 9 24 102 91 5 116 12 3 6 12 19 8 .349 .438 .552 .990 *6 15 Matt Stairs 153 175 410 1997 29 OAK AL 133 352 62 105 19 0 27 73 50 1 60 3 1 4 6 3 2 .298 .386 .582 .968 97D/3 16 Ben Oglivie 153 170 660 1980 31 MIL AL 156 592 94 180 26 2 41 118 54 19 71 5 0 9 5 11 9 .304 .362 .563 .925 *7/D98 17 Robin Yount 152 170 690 1989 33 MIL AL 160 614 101 195 38 9 21 103 63 9 71 6 3 4 9 19 3 .318 .384 .511 .895 *8D 18 Robin Yount 150 170 662 1983 27 MIL AL 149 578 102 178 42 10 17 80 72 6 58 3 1 8 11 12 5 .308 .383 .503 .886 *6/D 19 Amos Otis 150 166 567 1978 31 KCR AL 141 486 74 145 30 7 22 96 66 7 54 4 1 10 10 32 8 .298 .380 .525 .905 *8/D 20 Willie McGee 147 175 652 1985 26 STL NL 152 612 114 216 26 18 10 82 34 2 86 0 1 5 3 56 16 .353 .384 .503 .887 *8/7 21 Rich Aurilia 146 170 689 2001 29 SFG NL 156 636 114 206 37 5 37 97 47 2 83 0 3 3 14 1 3 .324 .369 .572 .941 *6 22 Julio Franco 146 165 659 1991 32 TEX AL 146 589 108 201 27 3 15 78 65 8 78 3 0 2 13 36 9 .341 .408 .474 .882 *4 23 Don Mattingly 146 175 629 1987 26 NYY AL 141 569 93 186 38 2 30 115 51 13 38 1 0 8 16 1 4 .327 .378 .559 .937 *3/D 24 Chase Utley 145 170 613 2007 28 PHI NL 132 530 104 176 48 5 22 103 50 1 89 25 1 7 7 9 1 .332 .410 .566 .976 *4/3 25 Jose Cruz 145 175 685 1984 36 HOU NL 160 600 96 187 28 13 12 95 73 10 68 0 2 10 8 22 8 .312 .381 .462 .843 *7 26 Sixto Lezcano 145 175 559 1982 28 SDP NL 138 470 73 136 26 6 16 84 78 10 69 2 2 7 11 2 1 .289 .388 .472 .860 *9
Mattingly fans, go crazy.
Interestingly, that fake list that was all over the internet yesterday morning mentioned one of the players who appears above. I don't want to say who, since it's not right to bring up that player's name AGAIN since he didn't ultimately appear in the Mitchell report. Doesn't mean any of these above guys are clean, of course.
Hey, check this out. I searched for all players, 1977-2007, listed at 175 lbs or less who got 400+ PAs in that year, and then sorted them by year (actually the PI Batting Season Finder did all this work for me):
So everybody supposedly starting taking steroids in 1993, and then in 1994 the number of players getting 400+ PAs while weighing 175 lbs or less suddenly drops off. Interesting. And then when MLB puts any sort of testing in place in 2003, suddenly the number of players weighing 175 lbs or less shoots up. Interesting.
December 14th, 2007 at 10:09 am
Ordonez weighed 170 lbs last year? Umm, I don't think so.
December 14th, 2007 at 10:26 am
the PI may include height and weight, but i don't think i would trust it...Magglio was listed at 215 last year and i dont' think Adrian Beltre ever weighted less than 175, even in 2004
December 14th, 2007 at 10:29 am
I agree...that chart is probably a better indicator as there are likely systematic errors in individual player weight, but the proportion of lighter/heavier players is probably about right.
December 14th, 2007 at 10:49 am
Maybe I'm just simply looking at this but it also drops off in 1981. What do the years 1981 and 1994 have in common? They were both strike years. I understand there's drop-off in 1995 but wouldn't the fact that there was a work stoppage also contribute to the fact that there's a large drop-off?
December 14th, 2007 at 10:58 am
Yes, because fewer players could achieve 400 PAs. But 1981 was clearly an aberration because the level returned to normal in 1982. But it did not rebound after 1994, even though there were more teams than in earlier years. I could drop the minimum number of PAs to, say, 200 and I bet the graph looks the same.
December 14th, 2007 at 11:23 am
Cool! You can do all sorts of things with weight. For example, is Mel Ott the lightest weighing 500+ HR hitter? Who's the heaviest to get 100+ triples in a season? Or who's the heaviest to get 50+ SB in a season?