1951 Hall of Fame Voting

1950 1952

Baseball Writers

226 total ballots (170 votes needed for election)

Baseball Writers Table
												Batting Stats													Pitching Stats
Rk	Name	YoB	Votes	%vote	HOFm	HOFs	Yrs	WAR	WAR7	JAWS	Jpos	G	AB	R	H	HR	RBI	SB	BB	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	W	L	ERA	ERA+	WHIP	G	GS	SV	IP	H	HR	BB	SO	Pos Summary
1	Mel Ott	3rd	197	87.2%	216	69	22	110.9	53.9	82.4	56.7	2730	9456	1859	2876	511	1860	89	1708	.304	.414	.533	.947	155														*95H87/4
2	Jimmie Foxx	7th	179	79.2%	314	72	20	92.2	57.9	75.1	53.4	2317	8134	1751	2646	534	1922	87	1452	.325	.428	.609	1.038	163	1	0	1.52	261	1.141	10	2	0	23.2	13	0	14	11	*3H52/7196
3	Paul Waner HOF	5th	162	71.7%	253	61	20	74.8	43.3	59.1	56.7	2549	9459	1627	3152	113	1309	104	1091	.333	.404	.473	.878	134														*9H3/78
4	Harry Heilmann HOF	11th	153	67.7%	192	57	17	72.2	47.1	59.6	56.7	2147	7787	1291	2660	183	1543	113	856	.342	.410	.520	.930	148														93H8/47
5	Bill Terry HOF	11th	148	65.5%	169	42	14	56.6	43.4	50.0	53.4	1721	6428	1120	2193	154	1078	56	537	.341	.393	.506	.899	136														*3H/97
6	Dizzy Dean HOF	7th	145	64.2%	112	33	12	46.2	44.1	45.1	61.5	325	717	76	161	8	76	5	9	.225	.235	.301	.536	43	150	83	3.02	131	1.206	317	230	31	1967.1	1919	95	453	1163	*1/H
7	Bill Dickey HOF	6th	118	52.2%	178	56	17	56.4	35.4	45.9	44.3	1789	6300	930	1969	202	1209	36	678	.313	.382	.486	.868	127														*2H
8	Al Simmons HOF	7th	116	51.3%	226	63	20	68.3	45.6	57.0	53.4	2215	8759	1507	2927	307	1828	88	615	.334	.380	.535	.915	133														78H/93
9	Rabbit Maranville HOF	11th	110	48.7%	59	30	23	44.0	30.5	37.3	55.5	2670	10078	1256	2605	28	884	291	839	.258	.318	.340	.658	82														64/H5
10	Ted Lyons HOF	6th	71	31.4%	65	30	21	70.6	40.8	55.7	61.5	705	1563	162	364	5	149	0	73	.233	.270	.285	.556	45	260	230	3.67	118	1.348	594	484	25	4161.0	4489	222	1121	1073	*1H/9
11	Dazzy Vance HOF	12th	70	31.0%	89	35	16	60.3	49.6	55.0	61.5	442	971	68	146	7	75	1	79	.150	.219	.198	.417	10	197	140	3.24	125	1.230	442	349	12	2966.2	2809	132	840	2045	*1/H
12	Hank Greenberg HOF	4th	67	29.6%	188	46	13	55.5	46.5	51.0	53.4	1394	5193	1046	1628	331	1274	58	852	.313	.412	.605	1.017	159														*37/H
13	Gabby Hartnett HOF	8th	57	25.2%	121	48	20	55.5	30.7	43.1	44.3	1990	6432	867	1912	236	1179	28	703	.297	.370	.489	.858	126														*2H3
14	Joe Cronin HOF	5th	44	19.5%	151	55	20	64.7	43.6	54.2	55.5	2124	7579	1233	2285	170	1424	87	1059	.301	.390	.468	.857	119														*6H534/7
15	Ray Schalk HOF	12th	37	16.4%	56	25	18	33.0	25.7	29.4	44.3	1762	5306	579	1345	11	593	177	638	.253	.340	.316	.656	83														*2H
16	Charles Bender HOF	12th	35	15.5%	119	51	16	48.0	33.6	40.8	61.5	507	1147	102	243	6	116	20	75	.212	.266	.280	.546	66	212	127	2.46	112	1.113	459	334	34	3017.0	2645	40	712	1711	*1H/38745
17	Ross Youngs HOF	12th	34	15.0%	71	32	10	32.7	30.8	31.8	56.7	1211	4627	812	1491	42	592	153	550	.322	.399	.441	.839	130														*9/4H87
18	Max Carey HOF	8th	27	11.9%	79	36	20	55.6	33.5	44.6	58.2	2476	9363	1545	2665	70	802	738	1040	.285	.361	.386	.747	108														879H
19	Tony Lazzeri HOF	6th	27	11.9%	89	39	14	47.6	34.0	40.8	57.1	1740	6297	986	1840	178	1194	148	869	.292	.380	.467	.846	121														*456H/73
20	Hank Gowdy	10th	26	11.5%	6	25	17	23.6	18.1	20.8	44.3	1050	2735	270	738	21	321	59	311	.270	.351	.358	.709	104														*2H3
21	Lefty Gomez HOF	7th	23	10.2%	128	34	14	38.7	36.1	37.4	61.5	368	904	59	133	0	58	1	50	.147	.194	.159	.353	-7	189	102	3.34	125	1.352	368	320	10	2503.0	2290	138	1095	1468	*1
22	Hack Wilson HOF	7th	21	9.3%	112	39	12	38.7	36.0	37.4	58.2	1348	4760	884	1461	244	1063	52	674	.307	.395	.545	.940	144														*879H/4
23	Edd Roush HOF	12th	21	9.3%	74	36	18	45.8	31.8	38.8	58.2	1967	7363	1099	2376	68	981	268	484	.323	.369	.446	.815	126														*8H7/394
24	Pepper Martin	7th	19	8.4%	49	21	13	21.9	19.9	20.9	56.7	1189	4117	756	1227	59	501	146	369	.298	.358	.443	.801	113	0	0	2.25	215	1.000	2	0	0	4.0	2	0	2	0	589H7/1
25	Zack Wheat HOF	11th	19	8.4%	99	48	19	60.4	34.7	47.6	53.4	2410	9106	1289	2884	132	1248	205	650	.317	.367	.450	.817	129														*7H/89
26	Chuck Klein HOF	4th	15	6.6%	194	48	17	46.6	39.1	42.8	56.7	1753	6486	1168	2076	300	1201	79	601	.320	.379	.543	.922	137														*97H8/3
27	Waite Hoyt HOF	7th	13	5.8%	94	32	21	52.4	34.9	43.6	61.5	674	1287	96	255	0	100	0	40	.198	.223	.235	.458	20	237	182	3.59	112	1.340	674	425	53	3762.1	4037	154	1003	1206	*1
28	Lefty O'Doul	4th	13	5.8%	92	31	11	27.1	27.3	27.2	53.4	970	3264	624	1140	113	542	36	333	.349	.413	.532	.945	143	1	1	4.87	83	1.970	34	1	0	77.2	104	1	49	19	*7H91/8
29	Babe Adams	11th	12	5.3%	72	39	19	52.6	41.6	47.1	61.5	482	1019	79	216	3	75	1	53	.212	.252	.281	.532	50	194	140	2.76	118	1.092	482	354	16	2995.1	2841	67	430	1036	*1
30	Charlie Grimm	7th	9	4.0%	18	19	20	12.4	12.5	12.5	53.4	2166	7917	908	2299	79	1077	57	578	.290	.341	.397	.738	95														*3H/9758
31	Bucky Harris HOF	6th	9	4.0%	12	18	12	16.3	16.3	16.3	57.1	1263	4736	722	1297	9	508	167	472	.274	.352	.354	.706	86														*4/H659
32	Red Ruffing HOF	4th	9	4.0%	130	38	22	68.6	39.9	54.3	61.5	882	1937	207	521	36	273	1	97	.269	.306	.389	.695	81	273	225	3.80	109	1.341	624	538	18	4344.0	4284	254	1541	1987	*1H/79
33	Dave Bancroft HOF	8th	9	4.0%	85	29	16	50.0	38.0	44.0	55.5	1913	7182	1048	2004	32	591	145	827	.279	.355	.358	.714	98														*6/H457
34	Bill McKechnie HOF	4th	8	3.5%	7	1	11	3.3	6.2	4.8	56.3	846	2843	319	713	8	240	127	190	.251	.301	.313	.614	78														*5436H/89
35	Casey Stengel HOF	7th	8	3.5%	4	15	14	20.2	17.3	18.8	56.7	1277	4288	575	1219	60	535	131	437	.284	.356	.410	.766	120														*98H/7
36	Home Run Baker HOF	11th	8	3.5%	81	33	13	62.8	46.7	54.7	56.3	1575	5984	887	1838	96	991	235	473	.307	.363	.442	.805	135														*5H
37	Kiki Cuyler HOF	4th	8	3.5%	116	46	18	48.1	35.7	41.9	56.7	1879	7161	1305	2299	128	1065	328	676	.321	.386	.474	.860	125														98*7H
38	Red Faber HOF	8th	8	3.5%	89	37	20	63.8	40.8	52.3	61.5	670	1269	98	170	3	71	7	169	.134	.240	.161	.401	10	254	213	3.15	119	1.302	669	483	27	4086.2	4106	111	1213	1471	*1/H
39	Cy Williams	6th	7	3.1%	44	31	19	37.4	25.9	31.7	58.2	2002	6780	1024	1981	251	1005	115	690	.292	.365	.470	.835	125														89H7
40	Jim Bottomley HOF	4th	6	2.7%	99	42	16	35.8	29.6	32.7	53.4	1991	7471	1177	2313	219	1422	58	664	.310	.369	.500	.869	125														*3H/4
41	Red Rolfe	2nd	6	2.7%	74	21	10	28.9	27.0	28.0	56.3	1175	4827	942	1394	69	497	44	526	.289	.360	.413	.773	99														*56H
42	Smoky Joe Wood	9th	5	2.2%	68	39	14	40.2	34.6	37.4	61.5	697	1952	266	553	23	325	23	208	.283	.357	.411	.768	110	117	57	2.03	146	1.087	225	158	10	1434.1	1138	10	421	989	917H/843
43	Eppa Rixey HOF	8th	5	2.2%	75	35	21	55.9	34.2	45.1	61.5	694	1522	95	291	3	111	2	49	.191	.221	.224	.445	22	266	251	3.15	115	1.272	692	554	14	4494.2	4633	93	1082	1350	*1/H
44	Burleigh Grimes HOF	7th	5	2.2%	115	38	19	52.9	41.1	47.0	61.5	632	1535	157	380	2	168	15	69	.248	.282	.306	.588	58	270	212	3.53	108	1.365	616	497	18	4180.0	4412	148	1295	1512	*1/H
45	Travis Jackson HOF	4th	4	1.8%	28	29	15	44.2	35.3	39.8	55.5	1656	6086	833	1768	135	929	71	412	.291	.337	.433	.770	102														65H/49
46	Billy Southworth HOF	5th	4	1.8%	11	19	13	21.7	20.3	21.0	56.7	1192	4359	661	1296	52	561	138	402	.297	.359	.415	.773	111														*987H/4
47	Al Schacht	3rd	4	1.8%	0	0	3	0.1	0.1	0.1	32.5	53	51	9	10	0	4	0	9	.196	.339	.235	.574	55	14	10	4.48	86	1.599	53	18	3	197.0	254	4	61	38	1
48	Art Fletcher	8th	4	1.8%	18	17	13	47.1	36.8	42.0	55.5	1533	5541	684	1534	32	676	160	203	.277	.319	.365	.684	100														*654/H
49	Art Nehf	6th	4	1.8%	71	32	15	28.9	24.8	26.9	61.5	464	915	90	192	8	76	7	86	.210	.281	.279	.560	57	184	120	3.20	105	1.239	451	320	14	2707.2	2715	107	640	844	*1/H987
50	Stuffy McInnis	7th	3	1.3%	43	23	19	34.7	25.2	30.0	53.4	2128	7822	871	2405	20	1063	172	380	.307	.343	.381	.723	105														*3H6/547
51	Stan Hack	4th	3	1.3%	76	38	16	55.5	37.4	46.4	56.3	1938	7278	1239	2193	57	642	165	1092	.301	.394	.397	.791	119														*5H3
52	Harry Hooper HOF	6th	3	1.3%	35	34	17	53.5	30.2	41.8	56.7	2309	8785	1429	2466	75	816	375	1136	.281	.368	.387	.755	114	0	0	0.00		1.500	1	0	0	2.0	2	0	1	0	*97H/81
53	Rube Marquard HOF	9th	3	1.3%	84	31	18	32.5	30.3	31.4	61.5	536	1107	63	198	1	66	6	33	.179	.207	.202	.410	17	201	177	3.08	103	1.237	536	408	20	3306.2	3233	107	858	1593	*1
54	Steve O'Neill	4th	3	1.3%	46	26	17	26.4	20.5	23.4	44.3	1590	4795	448	1259	13	534	30	592	.263	.349	.337	.685	88														*2H/3
55	Dickey Kerr	7th	3	1.3%	22	12	4	10.1	10.1	10.1	61.5	143	275	40	60	0	21	4	28	.218	.295	.284	.579	54	53	34	3.84	99	1.388	140	83	6	811.1	876	24	250	235	1/H
56	Jimmy Dykes	4th	3	1.3%	27	30	22	34.8	21.5	28.2	56.3	2282	8046	1108	2256	108	1069	70	958	.280	.365	.399	.764	96	0	0	4.50	111	1.500	2	0	1	2.0	2	0	1	0	5436H/8719
57	Ernie Lombardi HOF	2nd	3	1.3%	133	42	17	37.7	24.0	30.8	44.3	1853	5855	601	1792	190	990	8	430	.306	.358	.460	.818	126														2H
58	Duffy Lewis	5th	2	0.9%	16	12	11	21.2	21.1	21.2	53.4	1459	5351	612	1518	38	791	113	352	.284	.333	.384	.717	108	0	0	18.00	25	3.000	1	0	0	1.0	3	0	0	1	*7H/8951
59	Jimmie Wilson	4th	2	0.9%	45	26	18	11.2	10.6	10.9	44.3	1525	4778	580	1358	32	621	86	356	.284	.336	.370	.707	82														*2H/34879
60	George Selkirk	4th	2	0.9%	29	23	9	23.5	23.2	23.3	56.7	846	2790	503	810	108	576	49	486	.290	.400	.483	.883	127														97H/8
61	Everett Scott	9th	2	0.9%	29	14	13	16.7	16.0	16.4	55.5	1654	5837	552	1455	20	555	69	243	.249	.281	.315	.596	65														*6/H54
62	Sherry Magee	8th	2	0.9%	61	35	16	59.4	38.7	49.0	53.4	2087	7441	1112	2169	83	1176	441	736	.291	.364	.427	.790	137														*7839H6/45
63	Babe Herman	5th	1	0.4%	74	39	13	39.5	31.3	35.4	56.7	1552	5603	882	1818	181	997	94	520	.324	.383	.532	.915	141														*937H
64	Dick Bartell	2nd	1	0.4%	67	32	18	41.6	30.2	35.9	55.5	2016	7629	1130	2165	79	710	109	748	.284	.355	.391	.747	96														*654H
65	Glenn Wright	4th	1	0.4%	33	27	11	25.3	24.5	24.9	55.5	1119	4153	584	1219	94	723	38	209	.294	.328	.447	.775	99														*6H/3459
66	Clyde Milan	3rd	1	0.4%	24	23	16	40.0	28.0	34.0	58.2	1982	7359	1004	2100	17	617	495	685	.285	.353	.353	.706	109														*87H9
67	Charlie Gelbert	4th	1	0.4%	15	5	9	9.3	10.6	10.0	55.5	876	2869	398	766	17	350	34	290	.267	.336	.374	.709	81	0	0	9.00	55	2.000	2	0	0	4.0	5	2	3	1	*65H/41
68	Tim Jordan	1st	1	0.4%	8	8	7	11.2	11.2	11.2	53.4	540	1813	220	474	32	232	48	254	.261	.355	.382	.737	137														*3/H
69	Chick Hafey HOF	4th	1	0.4%	68	33	13	31.3	28.1	29.7	53.4	1283	4625	777	1466	164	833	70	372	.317	.372	.526	.898	133														*789H
70	Spud Chandler	2nd	1	0.4%	70	32	11	24.4	24.0	24.2	61.5	211	548	53	110	9	45	0	20	.201	.234	.290	.524	42	109	43	2.84	132	1.205	211	184	6	1485.0	1327	64	463	614	1
71	Jack Coombs	5th	1	0.4%	95	30	14	26.7	27.3	27.0	61.5	460	1110	123	261	4	100	21	59	.235	.278	.295	.573	74	158	110	2.78	99	1.239	354	268	8	2320.0	2034	38	841	1052	*1H9/873
72	Lloyd Waner HOF	3rd	1	0.4%	89	31	18	29.8	23.7	26.8	58.2	1993	7772	1201	2459	27	598	67	420	.316	.353	.393	.747	99														*8H79/45
73	Wilbur Cooper	5th	1	0.4%	76	33	15	53.4	42.0	47.7	61.5	521	1227	111	293	6	106	12	47	.239	.269	.309	.578	61	216	178	2.89	116	1.226	517	406	14	3480.0	3415	103	853	1252	*1/H79
74	Pinky Higgins	2nd	1	0.4%	27	30	14	26.0	20.1	23.1	56.3	1802	6636	931	1941	140	1075	61	800	.292	.370	.428	.798	107														*5H/46
75	Jake Daubert	4th	1	0.4%	71	27	15	39.4	25.9	32.7	53.4	2014	7673	1117	2326	56	722	251	623	.303	.360	.401	.760	117														*3/H
76	Mel Harder	3rd	1	0.4%	51	21	20	44.3	38.0	41.1	61.5	584	1203	89	199	4	93	2	39	.165	.194	.215	.409	7	223	186	3.80	113	1.408	582	433	24	3426.1	3706	161	1118	1161	*1/H
77	Paul Derringer	3rd	1	0.4%	99	28	15	36.0	26.4	31.2	61.5	579	1260	70	220	2	102	0	16	.175	.186	.208	.394	9	223	212	3.46	108	1.282	579	445	29	3645.0	3912	158	761	1507	*1
78	Bill Sherdel	4th	1	0.4%	37	16	15	31.1	24.0	27.6	61.5	549	960	96	214	9	86	2	63	.223	.271	.298	.569	52	165	146	3.72	104	1.358	514	273	26	2709.1	3018	150	661	839	*1H/93
79	Satchel Paige HOF	1st	1	0.4%	70	32	22	46.9	27.1	37.0	61.5	422	672	51	137	1	49	7	14	.204	.221	.241	.462	28	124	82	2.73	150	1.101	403	198	44	1751.2	1466	44	463	1501	*1/397
80	Hub Pruett	3rd	1	0.4%	0	0	7	2.4	2.4	2.4	32.5	211	212	9	36	0	12	0	21	.170	.245	.203	.447	17	29	48	4.63	92	1.627	211	69	13	745.0	816	27	396	357	1
81	Sam Rice HOF	5th	1	0.4%	127	51	20	54.3	31.1	42.7	56.7	2404	9269	1514	2987	34	1077	351	708	.322	.374	.427	.801	112	1	1	2.52	117	1.271	9	3	0	39.1	31	0	19	12	98H7/1
82	Joe McCarthy HOF	3rd	1	0.4%
83	Howard Ehmke	3rd	1	0.4%	32	12	15	39.1	32.6	35.9	61.5	429	1009	71	210	0	73	5	26	.208	.228	.258	.486	29	166	166	3.75	104	1.388	427	338	15	2820.2	2873	103	1042	1030	*1/H
84	Muddy Ruel	3rd	1	0.4%	49	28	19	20.9	19.5	20.2	44.3	1468	4514	494	1242	4	536	61	606	.275	.365	.332	.697	83														*2H/3
85	Dick Rudolph	2nd	1	0.4%	46	22	13	23.1	24.7	23.9	61.5	284	698	46	131	2	56	9	53	.188	.248	.234	.482	46	121	109	2.66	105	1.158	279	240	8	2049.0	1971	35	402	786	1/H
86	Eddie Rommel	4th	1	0.4%	49	23	13	49.7	37.4	43.6	61.5	508	826	80	164	1	59	1	62	.199	.255	.245	.499	28	171	119	3.54	121	1.350	501	249	30	2557.0	2729	138	724	599	*1/7H49

Notes: Each voting cycle, qualified members of the BBWAA name no more than 10 eligible players whom they consider worthy of Hall of Fame honors. To be enshrined, a player must be named on at least 75% of the voters' ballots. Currently, players are removed from the ballot if they are named on fewer than 5% of ballots or have been on the ballot 15 times without election. Changed to 10 times prior to the 2015 election.

"X" means off ballot for future elections. "HOF" means they were selected to the Hall of Fame in a future election.

More Awards Pages

Gold Gloves

Hall of Fame

Hall of Fame Registers

Hall of Fame Voting

Weekly/Monthly Awards

Other Awards

1951 Hall of Fame Voting

Baseball Writers

More Awards Pages

Full Site Menu

FAQs, Tip & Tricks