This is our old blog. It hasn't been active since 2011. Please see the link above for our current blog or click the logo above to see all of the great data and content on this site.

Archive for the 'Card of the Week' Category

Card of the Week: 1991 Donruss #592 Charles Nagy

14th July 2010

Card of the Week has moved to Wednesdays!

(click on images for larger versions)

This is a wonderful baseball card that shows you everything great about the hobby. This photo for the 1991 set was taken in spring training of 1990. Nagy was a minor-leaguer, hoping to make it to the show that year. He's fresh-faced, and he's not even standing on the field--he's behind a couple of chain-link fences with a tractor and a big trash barrel visible in the background.

What a totally unique photo!

Ummm...

Except for the fact that his 1991 Upper Deck photo is almost identical!

If you look carefully at the two cards, you can see that the photos were probably taken by different photographers. That would make sense, since teams usually hired their own personnel to go take the photos (as opposed to buying them from free-lancers who might sell different photos to different card companies.) Aside from the different facial expression Nagy's making, notice that the fence to the right is in a very different position. The Upper Deck photograph must have been a couple of steps to the right, creating more space between Nagy and that fence. Also notice that the clouds are further to the right behind Nagy, although they might have moved a bit between photos.

In any event, these two photos were probably taken within a few seconds of each other.

Getting back to the 1991 Donruss card, I really hated this design. They added all those stripes with random color and texture. They add absolutely nothing to the card. (For collectors, they remind me of the 1990 Topps design, with all their random colored borders...really annoying.) For comparison purposes, just look at the clean and classy 1991 Upper Deck design. Despite Nagy's funny face, it's quite the superior card.

Nagy holds the distinction of being the last pitcher to get a hit in the All-Star game:

Cr# Date Batter Tm Lg Pitcher Score Inn RoB Out RBI Play Description
1 1933-07-06 Lefty Gomez NYY AL Bill Hallahan tied 0-0 b 2 12- 2 1 Single to CF; Dykes Scores; Cronin to 2B
2 1933-07-06 Lon Warneke CHC NL General Crowder down 0-3 t 6 --- 1 0 Triple to RF
3 1934-07-10 Red Ruffing NYY AL Van Mungo ahead 6-4 t 5 123 1 2 Single to LF; Dickey Scores; Averill Scores; Gehringer to 2B
4 1940-07-09 Bobo Newsom DET AL Whit Wyatt down 0-3 t 6 --- 0 0 Single to RF
5 1941-07-08 Bucky Walters CIN NL Thornton Lee down 0-1 t 6 --- 0 0 Double to LF (Line Drive to LF Line)
6 1943-07-13 Dutch Leonard WSH AL Mort Cooper ahead 3-1 b 2 --- 1 0 Single to RF
7 1944-07-11 Hank Borowy NYY AL Bucky Walters tied 0-0 t 2 --3 2 1 Single to CF; Keltner Scores
8 1946-07-09 Hal Newhouser DET AL Kirby Higbe ahead 3-0 b 5 1-- 1 0 Single to CF (LF-CF); Rosar to 3B; Newhouser to 2B/Adv on throw to 3B
9 1946-07-09 Jack Kramer SLB AL Rip Sewell ahead 8-0 b 8 1-- 1 0 Single to LF; Stirnweiss to 3B
10 1948-07-13 Vic Raschi NYY AL Johnny Schmitz tied 2-2 b 4 123 1 2 Single to LF; Keltner Scores; McQuinn Scores; Tebbetts to 3B
11 1951-07-10 Don Newcombe BRO NL Mel Parnell ahead 8-3 t 8 --- 2 0 Single to RF
12 1953-07-14 Murry Dickson PIT NL Satchel Paige ahead 4-0 b 8 1-3 2 1 Single (Short LF-CF); Snider Scores; Slaughter to 3B; Dickson out at 2B/CF-3B-2B
13 1957-07-09 Billy Pierce CHW AL Clem Labine ahead 3-2 t 9 --- 0 0 Single to 2B
14 1958-07-08 Ray Narleski CLE AL Warren Spahn down 1-3 b 2 1-- 2 0 Single to CF; Aparicio to 2B
15 1962-07-30 Johnny Podres LAD NL Dave Stenhouse tied 0-0 b 2 --- 2 0 Double (CF-RF)
16 1963-07-09 Ken McBride LAA AL Jim O'Toole down 0-1 b 2 12- 2 1 Single to LF; Wagner Scores; Versalles to 3B; McBride to 2B/Adv on throw to Hm
17 1965-07-13 Juan Marichal SFG NL Mudcat Grant ahead 3-0 t 2 --- 0 0 Single to CF
18 1969-07-23 Steve Carlton STL NL Blue Moon Odom ahead 7-1 t 3 -2- 1 1 Double (LF-CF); Millan Scores
19 1992-07-14 Charles Nagy CLE AL Doug Jones ahead 10-1 t 8 --- 0 0 Single (Ground Ball)
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 7/13/2010.

This doesn't include last night, on the off chance a pitcher got a hit (can you tell I wrote this on Tuesday?) It also doesn't include any pitchers who might have gotten a hit as a pinch-hitter.

The last pitcher to get an extra-base hit was Steve Carlton in 1969 and the last pitcher to triple was Lon Warneke in 1933. The only pitcher to appear on this list twice is Bucky Walters--he got a hit in 1941 and surrendered one to a pitcher in 1944.


Posted in Card of the Week | 17 Comments »

Card of the Week: 1955 Topps #17 Bobby Hofman

10th July 2010

Starting next week, Card of the Week moves to Wednesdays.

(Click on images for larger versions)

Here we have one of the classic sets, 1955 Topps. So much has been said about this set in other places, I don't feel I have much to add. See the end of the post for some links to other sites that talk about the set.

One interesting thing, for total card newbies, is you'll notice that the picture on the front is a drawing and not a photograph. That's the way virtually all card sets before the 1960s were, I assume because of the cost and technical limitations of photography at the time.

Another thing to love about this set is the use of multiple pictures, in the sense that the drawing features both a headshot and an action shot. The illustration along with the simple but bold name banner, the background color fade, and the crisp back of the card make this set simply wonderful.

Bobby Hofman makes an interesting list of players since 1901 to play at least 10 games at both catcher and second base in the same season:

Rk Player Year Age Tm Lg G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS Pos
1 Scott Hemond 1994 28 OAK AL 91 216 198 23 44 11 0 3 20 16 51 .222 .280 .323 .604 245/379
2 Tom Satriano 1968 27 CAL AL 111 335 297 20 75 9 0 8 35 37 44 .253 .337 .364 .701 *245/3
3 Marty Martinez 1968 26 ATL NL 113 395 356 34 82 5 3 0 12 29 28 .230 .291 .261 .552 6542
4 Tom Satriano 1967 26 CAL AL 90 230 201 13 45 7 0 4 21 28 25 .224 .319 .318 .637 524/3
5 Don Zimmer 1965 34 WSA AL 95 258 226 20 45 6 0 2 17 26 59 .199 .284 .252 .536 254
6 Tom Satriano 1965 24 CAL AL 47 89 79 8 13 2 0 1 4 10 10 .165 .258 .228 .486 542/3
7 Bobby Hofman 1955 29 NYG NL 96 232 207 32 55 7 2 10 28 22 31 .266 .336 .464 .800 342/5
8 Moe Berg 1927 25 CHW AL 35 77 69 4 17 4 0 0 4 4 10 .246 .288 .304 .592 42/65
9 Grover Hartley 1914 25 SLM FL 86 233 212 24 61 13 2 1 25 12 26 .288 .329 .382 .711 24/358
10 Roger Bresnahan 1914 35 CHC NL 101 311 248 42 69 10 4 0 24 49 20 .278 .401 .351 .752 *24/8
11 Heinie Peitz 1902 31 CIN NL 112 428 387 54 122 22 5 1 60 24 0 .315 .369 .406 .775 42/35
12 Heinie Peitz 1901 30 CIN NL 82 296 269 24 82 13 5 1 24 23 0 .305 .364 .401 .765 *24/53
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 7/9/2010.

In 1955 Hoffman actually played 19 each at catcher and second base, another 24 at first base, and 5 at third base. Over the course of his career, he played a bunch at all 4 positions, including more than 40 games at 1B, 2B, and 3B.

Hoffman had some serious power, it would seem. In 1953 he hit 12 HR with 34 RBI in just 182 plate appearances. At the moment, his most similar batters list includes Ian Stewart and Ben Zobrist. That's because Hofman didn't hit or play much in 1956 and 1957 and didn't play in the majors again. He finished his career with a little over a full season's plate appearances (755) with 32 HR and 101 RBI.

Take a peek down at the back of the card. You gotta love the Puzzlers trivia question, along with the graphic showing 3 players wearing collars.

I don't know if the 1908 Cardinals still hold the record for most times getting shutout. Doing a quick Team Batting Game Finder search for runs = 0 reveals this list:

Rk Tm Year #Matching W L
1 NYM 1963 30 0 30 Ind. Games
2 TEX 1972 27 0 27 Ind. Games
3 NYM 1967 26 0 26 Ind. Games
4 WSH 1955 24 0 24 Ind. Games
5 ATL 1978 24 0 24 Ind. Games
6 SDP 1976 23 0 23 Ind. Games
7 SDP 1969 23 0 23 Ind. Games
8 LAD 1968 23 0 23 Ind. Games
9 HOU 1963 23 0 23 Ind. Games
10 CIN 1920 23 0 22 Ind. Games
11 CHW 1968 23 0 23 Ind. Games
12 CAL 1971 23 0 23 Ind. Games
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 7/9/2010.

The search covers 1920-1939 and 1952-present. Since the '08 Cards held the record as of 1954 (when this Hofman card was printed) and the search covers back to 1952, I presume that team still holds the record.

Further reading:

Posted in Card of the Week | 9 Comments »

Card of the Week: 1993 Topps Traded #12T A. J. Hinch

3rd July 2010

(click on images for larger versions)

Well, the experiment is over. A. J. Hinch has been relieved of his managerial duties in Arizona. A move that made sense to very few people at the time has been reversed.

Topps started putting Olympics cards in their sets in 1985. These were cards for the players on the American team in the Olympics. That 1985 set includes the first cards for future major-leaguers including Mark McGwire, Cory Snyder, and Oddibe McDowell. They next included them in the 1988 Topps Traded set to cover the players from Team USE in the 1988 summer Olympics. That set included rookie cards for Jim Abbott, Robin Ventura, Mickey Morandini, Charles Nagy, and Andy Benes.

I'm not entirely sure what these 1993 cards represent. If they were players from the 1992 Olympic team, I'm not sure why they weren't part of the regular 1993 set, plus Hinch was not on the 1992 Olympic team. Anyway, within the 1993 Topps Traded Team USA cards are rookie issues for Carlton Loewer, Todd Helton, Dustin Hermanson, Todd Walker, Danny Graves, and Paul Wilson.

The 1993 Topps design is nice. I believe this was the first regular-issue Topps set that included photos on the back (this was true for both the regular 1993 Topps set and the 1993 Topps Traded set.) It makes for a nice card with a big photo on the front, small headshot on the back, nice colors and basic design, and the traditional stats and bio. A nice, traditional set.

Please leave a comment below with a caption for the photo above, telling us what Hinch was thinking as this photo was taken.

Hinch did not have a particularly notable major-league career as either a player or manager.

Let's take a look at some of his career achievements, such as they are:

  • He had 26 go-ahead plate appearances, although only one of them came in the 7th inning or later. That was in this game when his 7th-inning single scored Dave Magadan to break a 1-1 tie.
  • He homered off 31 different pitchers, but just one of them, Kelvim Escobar, gave up more than 1 to Hinch.
  • The most RBI he had in a game was 4, twice:
    Rk Date Tm Opp Rslt PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO WPA RE24 aLI BOP Pos. Summary
    1 2002-05-14 KCR MIN W 8-1 4 4 2 2 0 0 1 4 0 0 0.085 1.938 .780 8 C
    2 1999-08-14 OAK TOR W 13-5 5 5 1 1 0 0 1 4 0 0 0.093 0.949 .236 9 C
    Provided by

Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 7/2/2010.

I don't have too much else to say about Hinch, except this: I think it's a shame that he became a manager so early in his career. He would have been well-served to manage in the minors for a while. He was a victim of a poorly-run Diamondbacks organization (the same one that just fired a GM with no previous head-GM experience and more than 5 years remaining on his contract.) I am afraid that we might never see Hinch on the field again--a fate much worse than he deserves.

Posted in Card of the Week | 7 Comments »

Card of the Week: 1984 Topps #705 NL Active Stolen Base Leaders

26th June 2010

(Click images for larger versions)

Ahh, the 1984 Topps set. This one is pretty well-liked by many collectors. As Night Owl has pointed out, the design is a fairly straightforward evolution of the successful 1983 set. (He also ranks it as the 8th best set of the 30-some main sets produced in the 1980s by Topps, Fleer, Donruss, Score, and Upper Deck.) Ben Henry of The Baseball Card Blog puts both 1984 Topps and 1984 Topps Traded in his top 30 sets of the 1980s (his list includes 53 sets.) Ben includes a nice writeup of the set on that post.

The card I chose, NL Active Stolen Base Leaders, isn't terribly representative of the set since it's a multi-player card from a small subset. Click those links above to see examples of more traditional cards from the set. I picked this particular card because of the three intriguing players featured.

Let's start with Joe Morgan. This the only Morgan card I've ever seen that shows him in the pinstriped home Phillies uniform. (I'm tempted to count the 1984 Fleer "Reds reunited card".) Morgan spent just one year with the Phillies and, despite a .230 batting average still had a 116 OPS+ and 3.4 WAR.

A stat like WAR really helps show just how incredible Morgan was at his peak. Most players never even sniff a 10.0 WAR season but Morgan had 3 of them (1972, and of course the incredible seasons of 1975 and 1976.) In those 2 middle years of 1973 and 1974 he managed WARs of "only" 9.9 and 9.1.

Check out Morgan's overall lead in WAR from 1972 to 1976:

Rk Player WAR/pos Age G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS BA OBP SLG OPS Pos Tm
1 Joe Morgan 51.0 28-32 742 3257 2610 565 792 146 20 108 427 592 267 310 63 .303 .431 .499 .930 *4 CIN
2 Rod Carew 33.2 26-30 743 3242 2854 431 983 134 38 32 338 310 256 175 69 .344 .407 .452 .858 *43/D MIN
3 Cesar Cedeno 32.5 21-25 719 3100 2769 466 826 160 23 104 400 278 347 276 85 .298 .365 .485 .850 *8 HOU
4 Johnny Bench 32.1 24-28 736 3168 2711 423 719 140 9 142 542 409 460 39 13 .265 .359 .481 .840 *2/9537 CIN
5 Bobby Grich 32.0 23-27 749 3205 2665 414 701 136 24 69 293 443 491 75 42 .263 .374 .410 .784 *4/635D BAL
6 Reggie Jackson 31.8 26-30 725 3032 2635 436 724 144 10 149 480 342 582 101 36 .275 .361 .507 .867 *98/D OAK-BAL
7 Pete Rose 31.5 31-35 801 3774 3304 574 1038 201 36 31 309 419 246 31 20 .314 .396 .425 .821 *75/9 CIN
8 Mike Schmidt 28.0 22-26 625 2548 2115 358 532 104 14 131 373 374 618 74 35 .252 .369 .500 .869 *5/643 PHI
9 Sal Bando 26.8 28-32 778 3221 2737 384 678 115 11 108 440 409 372 36 13 .248 .348 .416 .764 *5/6D4 OAK
10 Jim Wynn 25.3 30-34 712 3002 2419 466 594 95 13 111 377 539 493 72 42 .246 .381 .433 .814 897 HOU-LAD-ATL
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/25/2010.

That, my friends, is what we call a blowout. Incidentally, he has just as big a lead when looking at just Batting Runs, too.

Two other things of note about that list above:

  • With 3 players in the top 7, the Reds should have been called the Big WAR Machine.
  • Check out who's at number 3...our next subject.

Cesar Cedeno might be the most underrated player in the last 40 years. A lot of people have never even heard of the guy, which is almost inexplicable. Cedeno came up with the Astros fairly close to the time when they traded Morgan away to Cincinnati. Interestingly, Cedeno later went to the Reds a couple of years after Morgan left there, too.

Cedeno's peak was at nearly the exact same time as Morgan's, and as you can see above he racked up the 3rd most WAR in all of MLB from 1972-1976.

Here are the leaders (1901-present) for career WAR among centerfielders (minimum half career games in CF):

Rk Player WAR/pos From To Age
1 Ty Cobb 159.4 1905 1928 18-41
2 Willie Mays 154.7 1951 1973 20-42
3 Tris Speaker 133.0 1907 1928 19-40
4 Mickey Mantle 120.2 1951 1968 19-36
5 Joe DiMaggio 83.6 1936 1951 21-36
6 Ken Griffey 78.4 1989 2010 19-40
7 Duke Snider 67.5 1947 1964 20-37
8 Jim Edmonds 67.2 1993 2010 23-40
9 Kenny Lofton 65.3 1991 2007 24-40
10 Jim Wynn 59.8 1963 1977 21-35
11 Andruw Jones 58.7 1996 2010 19-33
12 Richie Ashburn 58.0 1948 1962 21-35
13 Willie Davis 57.2 1960 1979 20-39
14 Carlos Beltran 54.7 1998 2009 21-32
15 Cesar Cedeno 52.2 1970 1986 19-35
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/25/2010.

Cedeno's 15th all-time, ahead of Bernie Williams, Johnny Damon, Ellis Burks, Vada Pinson, Fred Lynn, Kirby Puckett, Eric Davis and anybody else you don't see above. His 1972 seasons ranks as one of the 10 best by a centerfielder from the last 40 years based on batting runs above replacement:

Rk Player Rbat Year Tm G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS Pos
1 Bobby Murcer 58 1971 NYY 146 624 529 94 175 25 6 25 94 91 60 .331 .427 .543 .969 *8
2 Fred Lynn 56 1979 BOS 147 622 531 116 177 42 1 39 122 82 79 .333 .423 .637 1.059 *8/D
3 Jim Edmonds 54 2004 STL 153 612 498 102 150 38 3 42 111 101 150 .301 .418 .643 1.061 *8/D3
4 Bernie Williams 54 1998 NYY 128 578 499 101 169 30 5 26 97 74 81 .339 .422 .575 .997 *8/D
5 Ken Griffey 54 1997 SEA 157 704 608 125 185 34 3 56 147 76 121 .304 .382 .646 1.028 *8/D7
6 Brady Anderson 53 1996 BAL 149 687 579 117 172 37 5 50 110 76 106 .297 .396 .637 1.034 *8/D
7 Ken Griffey 53 1993 SEA 156 691 582 113 180 38 3 45 109 96 91 .309 .408 .617 1.025 *8D/3
8 Rickey Henderson 49 1985 NYY 143 654 547 146 172 28 5 24 72 99 65 .314 .419 .516 .934 *8/7D
9 Cesar Cedeno 49 1972 HOU 139 625 559 103 179 39 8 22 82 56 62 .320 .385 .537 .921 *8
10 Brian Giles 47 1999 PIT 141 627 521 109 164 33 3 39 115 95 80 .315 .418 .614 1.032 *89/7D
11 Jim Wynn 47 1974 LAD 150 656 535 104 145 17 4 32 108 108 104 .271 .387 .497 .884 *8
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/25/2010.

I've limited my discussion of Cedeno to a couple of all-encompassing stats but I encourage you to look more at his career and get to know this relatively anonymous guy who was once a major star player.

Larry Bowa, meanwhile is at the other end of the spectrum, so to speak.

Since 1901, Bowa has the worst batting runs above replacement in all of MLB:

Rk Player Rbat From To Age G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS BA OBP SLG OPS Pos Tm
1 Larry Bowa -307 1970 1985 24-39 2247 9103 8418 987 2191 262 99 15 525 474 569 318 105 .260 .300 .320 .620 *6/4 PHI-CHC-TOT
2 Alfredo Griffin -306 1976 1993 18-35 1962 7330 6780 759 1688 245 78 24 527 338 664 192 134 .249 .285 .319 .604 *6/45 CLE-TOR-OAK-LAD
3 Ozzie Guillen -294 1985 2000 21-36 1993 7133 6686 773 1764 275 69 28 619 239 511 169 108 .264 .287 .338 .626 *6/5347 CHW-TOT-ATL-TBD
4 Bill Bergen -291 1901 1911 23-33 947 3228 3028 138 516 45 21 2 193 88 81 23 0 .170 .194 .201 .395 *2/3 CIN-BRO
5 Tommy Thevenow -290 1924 1938 20-34 1229 4484 4164 380 1030 124 32 2 456 210 222 23 3 .247 .285 .294 .579 *645/3 STL-PHI-PIT-CIN-BSN
6 Ed Brinkman -268 1961 1975 19-33 1846 6640 6045 550 1355 201 38 60 461 444 845 30 35 .224 .280 .300 .580 *6/547 WSA-DET-TOT
7 Ski Melillo -250 1926 1937 26-37 1377 5536 5063 590 1316 210 64 22 548 327 306 69 64 .260 .306 .340 .646 *4/56 SLB-TOT-BOS
8 Don Kessinger -249 1964 1979 21-36 2078 8529 7651 899 1931 254 80 14 527 684 759 100 85 .252 .314 .312 .626 *6/453 CHC-STL-TOT-CHW
9 Mark Belanger -248 1965 1982 21-38 2016 6602 5784 676 1316 175 33 20 389 576 839 167 75 .228 .300 .280 .580 *6/45 BAL-LAD
10 Everett Scott -248 1914 1926 21-33 1654 6373 5837 552 1455 208 58 20 551 243 282 69 60 .249 .281 .315 .596 *6/54 BOS-NYY-TOT
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/25/2010.

Now, this shouldn't be misconstrued to mean that Bowa was the worst hitter in the big leagues. Clearly, there were many, many guys far worse than Bowa who were so bad that they didn't get enough playing time to amass such a big negative number. Bowa was, perhaps, the worst hitter among players good enough to deserve to play every day for a whole bunch of years. Just don't forget that he was good enough to play every day for a whole bunch of years.

Bowa's overall runs above replacement (RAR) for his career was +198, so he made up for his offensive deficiencies by being a really good defensive player at the most important defensive position (SS).

Since we're at the end of the post, let me just comment on the back of the card a little bit. I always like this dark blue back. Topps used very similar designs for all of the backs of their 1980s sets, but this one used by far the boldest colors.

It's amazing that Rickey Henderson, already a star in 1984, doesn't appear on the lists on the back of the card. These days, he's on the top of the all-time stolen base list.

Posted in Card of the Week | 11 Comments »

Card of the Week: 1995 Leaf Limited #89 John Valentin

19th June 2010

(click on images for larger versions)

Leaf started out in the 1980s as the Canadian version of Donruss. Starting in 1985, Donruss produced a mirror set with some modifications under the Leaf name to be released just in Canada. By the 1990s, though, Leaf became more of a premium edition card set. It wasn't a simple mirror of the base Donruss release nor was it limited to just Canada.

Still, most old-school collectors immediately think of Canada when they hear the name "Leaf" and that makes the design of this card, clearly invoking the American flag, ironic.

Overall I am fond of the design of this card. Yeah, there is a lot of red and there are a lot of stripes. But they used many different colors in the set and did a great job matching card colors to team colors. Each card featured a whopping 3 unique photos, which is simply fantastic, especially since one was a posed head shot and the other two were action shots. Look, for example, at Jay Buhner's card from this set, which features two great action shots and an interesting head shot, all with a great navy and green color scheme that matched that year's Mariners colors.

This card also features some foil, on both the Leaf name on the front and the circular patch on the back. One thing I find weird is the large text that says "Card Number", which seems needless. It mirrors the position text ("Shortstop", in this case) on the left side of the card but still doesn't make a lot of sense to me.

Using the stripes to act as line dividers for the stats on the back was a very nice touch.

Ahh, those stats on the back. Let's take a look at those.

All the way on the right we see Valentin's career stats including both SLG and OBP...nice. What really catches my eye, however, is the monthly split data. Back in 1995, this sort of data was extremely hard to come by unless you tabulated it yourself. Monthly split data has always been interesting to me. I like to see players who are consistent from month to month. All the games count the same so ideally a player should hit the same for the whole season. It seems that a number of players have slow Aprils--Mark Teixeira and Don Mattingly spring to mind--which always bothers me.

Notice how Valentin, through 1994, had 4 to6 homers every month except May, when he had 0 career homers in 95 AB?

Here are his career splits by month, 1992-2002:

I Split G AB H HR RBI BA OBP SLG
April/March 149 551 127 14 61 .230 .310 .374
May 185 675 190 20 98 .281 .364 .452
June 203 722 205 26 104 .284 .359 .467
July 191 673 207 21 101 .308 .390 .504
August 206 728 208 22 106 .286 .363 .459
Sept/Oct 171 568 156 21 88 .275 .360 .456
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 6/18/2010.

He caught up with his May numbers thanks in large part to 7 homers in May of 1995.

That brings me to John Valentin's 1995.

Check out the leaders in Wins Above Replacement (among batters) for 1995:

Rk Player WAR/pos Tm G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS BA OBP SLG OPS Pos
1 John Valentin 8.5 BOS 135 621 520 108 155 37 2 27 102 81 67 20 5 .298 .399 .533 .931 *6
2 Edgar Martinez 7.7 SEA 145 639 511 121 182 52 0 29 113 116 87 4 3 .356 .479 .628 1.107 *D/53
3 Barry Bonds 7.3 SFG 144 635 506 109 149 30 7 33 104 120 83 31 10 .294 .431 .577 1.009 *7
4 Tim Salmon 6.8 CAL 143 638 537 111 177 34 3 34 105 91 111 5 5 .330 .429 .594 1.024 *9/D
5 Reggie Sanders 6.7 CIN 133 567 484 91 148 36 6 28 99 69 122 36 12 .306 .397 .579 .975 *98
6 Albert Belle 6.6 CLE 143 629 546 121 173 52 1 50 126 73 80 5 2 .317 .401 .690 1.091 *7/D
7 Craig Biggio 6.6 HOU 141 673 553 123 167 30 2 22 77 80 85 33 8 .302 .406 .483 .889 *4
8 Chuck Knoblauch 6.5 MIN 136 629 538 107 179 34 8 11 63 78 95 46 18 .333 .424 .487 .911 *4/6
9 Mike Piazza 6.3 LAD 112 475 434 82 150 17 0 32 93 39 80 1 0 .346 .400 .606 1.006 *2
10 Bernie Williams 6.0 NYY 144 648 563 93 173 29 9 18 82 75 98 8 6 .307 .392 .487 .878 *8
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/18/2010.

Yup.Valentin was never an All-Star and finished 9th in the AL in MVP voting in 1995. Valentin finished first in WAR by putting together very solid seasons both with the bat and in the field at shortstop.

Posted in Card of the Week | 7 Comments »

Card of the Week: 1963 Fleer #47 Roger Craig

12th June 2010

(click images for larger versions)

Here we have a 1963 Fleer card featuring Roger Craig. I knew Fleer as only the card company from the 1980s and 1990s so I asked dayf from Cardboard Junkie to explain a bit of the history to me. Here's what he had to say:

"Basically, Fleer is the company that first developed a good quality bubble gum back in the '20s They'd been a long time confectioner before that and put out a cheap 'strip card' set that included Cobb and Ruth back in 1923. They had dabbled in bubble gum cards in the '30s but didn't really jump on the baseball card bandwagon until the '50s. By the time they got in, Bowman and Topps were already in huge legal battles over exclusive contracts and they had no good way of getting their foot in the door. They signed Ted Williams to a big exclusive contract in1959 and put out an 80 card set of all Ted which flopped. Then in 1960 and '61 they tried doing Legends sets of retired ballplayers and they didn't do much better. In 1963 they did a real baseball card set with a stale cookie instead of gum to skirt Topps' trademark of cards+gum, got sued and had to lay low through the rest of the '60s and '70s doing oddball sets and stickers. They sued again in the '70s and won, partly because Marvin Miller wanted to sell more card licenses to make the union some money. They sued again, won the case and got the right to put out a set in 1981. Then the card market exploded, they got in over their heads with some bad entertainment licenses, went bankrupt and are now a subsidiary of a failing card company.

So basically, yes, the '60s Fleer cards are the same company as the '80s Fleer cards with some stickers in the middle. Check out the fleer sticker project if you want to know what they were up to in the '70s."

The photo on this card is interesting and looks like it was taken late in the day. I like the silhouetted stadium in the background and the overall dark aspect of the card really highlights Craig's face.

From a design standpoint this card is a bit unusual. The yellow diamond depicting Craig's position is awfully large, especially given that it's a generic drawing (not of Craig specifically). The off-white area featuring the name, team, and position is also large given the amount of information it contains. Still, these features give the card a simple, clean look which is certainly welcome in comparison to some modern-day cards packed with all kinds of colors, marks, foil, chrome, and other nonsense.

The back of the card is equally simple and clean. Unusually, it features the card number near the center of the card.

Within the years we have box scores, the 1963 season by Roger Craig features the most losses where the starting pitcher allowed at most 1 earned run. These are tough-luck losses.

Rk Player Year #Matching W L W-L% ERA GS CG SHO SV IP H ER HR BB SO WHIP
1 Roger Craig 1963 8 Ind. Games 0 8 .000 0.86 8 5 0 0 63.0 52 6 2 12 32 1.02
2 Sam McDowell 1968 7 Ind. Games 0 7 .000 0.91 7 3 0 0 49.2 35 5 3 24 59 1.19
3 Jim Bunning 1967 7 Ind. Games 0 7 .000 1.09 7 2 0 0 57.2 32 7 2 14 46 0.80
4 Fred Newman 1965 6 Ind. Games 0 6 .000 1.18 6 2 0 0 45.2 33 6 2 9 18 0.92
5 Dana Fillingim 1920 6 Ind. Games 0 6 .000 0.87 6 3 0 0 41.1 38 4 1 10 13 1.16
6 Don Drysdale 1964 6 Ind. Games 0 6 .000 0.53 6 4 0 0 51.1 35 3 1 14 41 0.95
7 Paul Derringer 1933 6 Ind. Games 0 6 .000 1.31 6 0 0 0 34.1 33 5 0 7 14 1.17
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/3/2010.

As you can see, there are a number of good pitchers on this leader board

What's odd is the text on the back of Craig's card (see below.) It may sound like it refers to the 1963 season but of course the card was released before the season and instead refers to Craig's 1962, in which he also lost a bunch of games in which he didn't allow many runs. That year, the expansion Mets scored only 617 runs in comparison to the 948 they allowed while on their way to a 40-120 record. Craig actually lost only 1 game that year that he started and allowed no more than 1 earned run. In his entire career beyond 1963, he had only 7 such games, as compared to the 8 in 1963 alone.

Posted in Card of the Week | 3 Comments »

Card of the Week: 1989 Upper Deck #1 Ken Griffey Jr.

5th June 2010

(click images for larger versions)

I had another card planned for this week but with Ken Griffey Jr. retiring I decided to pinch-hit with this card.

The card we see here--the first card of the first set ever produced by Upper Deck--is one of the most important cards produced in the last 30 years. In the off-season before the 1989 season, Ken Griffey Jr. was the most-anticipated rookie coming that season (and most-anticipated in years.) Topps had survived challenges from Donruss and Fleer in 1981 and Score in 1988. However, they made a critical error in 1989, which was the omission of a card for Ken Griffey Jr. in the regular-issue 1989 set. This omission was keeping with Topps' tradition up to that point, when they usually did not issue cards for players who had not yet appeared in the major leagues. Donruss and Fleer did not make the same mistake, and neither did Upper Deck, who came on the scene with extremely high-quality cards featuring wonderful photography, high-gloss thick card stock, and the first use of holograms on major-release cards.

This Upper Deck Griffey card immediately became a fan-favorite fetching high prices at card shows and helping Upper Deck to sell out all of the cards and sets it produced for the 1989 season. By the end of the year, unopened packs were going for a premium well above the label price due to demand for the Griffey card. These days, a graded gem mint example of this card sells for $200-300 on eBay.

Topps obviously survived and had the last laugh thanks to the demise of Score, Fleer, Donruss, and Upper Deck losing its MLB license after last year. However, the lack of a Griffey card in 1989 was one major reason why Upper Deck got so much attention and cut into Topps' sales.

Let's talk about the photo used on this card. The picture has a lot to do with why the card was so popular. They could have used an action shot but recognized that this kid (or should I say "Kid" with a capital 'k'?) had a wonderful, enthusiastic smile and was going to bring joy and excitement to the game. They understood what Ken Griffey Jr. meant to the fans and that he was a special rookie, not just another phenom who was going to flame out.

What's funny about all of this is that it's easy to forget that Griffey didn't stat off on fire. In fact he finished, appropriately, as a distant third in the 1989 AL Rookie of the Year voting:

Voting Results Batting Stats Pitching Stats
Rank Tm Vote Pts 1st Place Share WAR G AB R H HR RBI SB BB BA OBP SLG OPS W L ERA WHIP G GS SV IP H HR BB SO
1 Gregg Olson BAL 136.0 26.0 97% 3.6 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 2 1.69 1.212 64 0 27 85.0 57 1 46 90
2 Tom Gordon KCR 67.0 1.0 48% 3.4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 9 3.64 1.276 49 16 1 163.0 122 10 86 153
3 Ken Griffey SEA 21.0 1.0 15% 2.8 127 455 61 120 16 61 16 44 .264 .329 .420 .748
4 Craig Worthington BAL 16.0 0.0 11% 1.4 145 497 57 123 15 70 1 61 .247 .334 .384 .718
5 Jim Abbott CAL 10.0 0.0 7% 0.2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 12 3.92 1.456 29 29 0 181.1 190 13 74 115
6 Kevin Brown TEX 2.0 0.0 1% 3.2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 9 3.35 1.241 28 28 0 191.0 167 10 70 104
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 6/4/2010.

In 1990, Griffey came to resemble the player we all know today. He hit .300, had an OPS+ of 135, and drove in 80 runs batting mainly 3rd and 5th for a fairly bad Mariners team.

After that, there was no looking back. Other than his injury-shortened 1995 season, Griffey went on to post 9 straight seasons with an OPS+ of at least 133.

In 1993-1994 he led the majors in homers:

Rk Player HR Age G PA AB R H 2B 3B RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS Pos Tm
1 Ken Griffey 85 23-24 267 1184 1015 207 320 62 7 199 152 164 .315 .405 .641 1.047 *8/D39 SEA
2 Barry Bonds 83 28-29 271 1148 930 218 303 56 5 204 200 122 .326 .445 .665 1.110 *7 SFG
3 Matt Williams 81 27-28 257 1102 1024 179 289 49 7 206 60 167 .282 .322 .581 .903 *5 SFG
4 Frank Thomas 79 25-26 266 1193 948 212 315 70 1 229 221 115 .332 .453 .658 1.111 *3/D CHW
5 Albert Belle 74 26-27 265 1173 1006 183 319 71 5 230 134 167 .317 .398 .618 1.016 *7/D CLE
6 Fred McGriff 71 29-30 264 1118 981 192 297 54 3 195 126 182 .303 .381 .581 .962 *3 TOT-ATL
7 Juan Gonzalez 65 23-24 247 1050 958 162 282 51 5 203 67 165 .294 .351 .562 .913 *7/D TEX
8 Joe Carter 60 33-34 266 1152 1038 162 271 58 7 224 80 177 .261 .314 .504 .818 *9/7D TOR
9 Rafael Palmeiro 60 28-29 271 1184 1033 206 315 72 2 181 127 148 .305 .380 .553 .933 *3 TEX-BAL
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/4/2010.

But that wasn't his only peak. From 1996 to 2000 you know that Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa were 102 in total HR, but Griffey was right there at #3:

Rk Player HR From To
1 Mark McGwire 277 1996 2000
2 Sammy Sosa 255 1996 2000
3 Ken Griffey 249 1996 2000
4 Rafael Palmeiro 206 1996 2000
5 Barry Bonds 202 1996 2000
6 Jeff Bagwell 197 1996 2000
7 Juan Gonzalez 195 1996 2000
8 Mo Vaughn 188 1996 2000
9 Albert Belle 187 1996 2000
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/4/2010.

Over that same period, he was way out in front in RBI:

Rk Player RBI From To
1 Ken Griffey 685 1996 2000
2 Sammy Sosa 656 1996 2000
3 Rafael Palmeiro 641 1996 2000
4 Albert Belle 636 1996 2000
5 Manny Ramirez 632 1996 2000
6 Juan Gonzalez 627 1996 2000
7 Jeff Bagwell 624 1996 2000
8 Dante Bichette 604 1996 2000
9 Mark McGwire 603 1996 2000
10 Frank Thomas 588 1996 2000
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/4/2010.

After 2000 he was never again injury free and didn't put up huge numbers again. He still had great seasons in 2005 (35 HR, 92 RBI, 144 OPS+) and 2007 (30 HR, 93 RBI, 119 OPS+.)

Griffey was also an amazing defensive centerfielder for the first half of his career. In 1996 he posted 32 total zone runs, the 4th-best season ever for a CF. That year Griffey also posted 9.6 Wins Above Replacement. Since then, just a handful of players have posted a higher number:

Rk Player WAR/pos Year Age Tm
1 Barry Bonds 12.5 2001 36 SFG
2 Barry Bonds 12.4 2004 39 SFG
3 Barry Bonds 12.2 2002 37 SFG
4 Sammy Sosa 11.4 2001 32 CHC
5 Alex Rodriguez 11.0 2000 24 SEA
6 Albert Pujols 10.9 2003 23 STL
7 Barry Bonds 10.8 1996 31 SFG
8 Barry Bonds 10.3 2003 38 SFG
9 Jason Giambi 10.3 2001 30 OAK
10 Adrian Beltre 10.1 2004 25 LAD
11 Alex Rodriguez 9.9 2007 31 NYY
12 Ken Griffey 9.7 1996 26 SEA
13 Albert Pujols 9.6 2008 28 STL
14 Craig Biggio 9.6 1997 31 HOU
15 Albert Pujols 9.4 2004 24 STL
16 Ken Griffey 9.4 1997 27 SEA
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 6/4/2010.

In short, this guy was a stud. He was arguably the very best player of the 1990s due to his play on both sides of the ball.

Further reading:

Check out my account of the time Griffey and his dad hit back-to-back homers in the same game. This is easily my favorite moment in baseball history.

Posted in Card of the Week | 50 Comments »

Card of the Week: 1982 Donruss #74 Carl Yastrzemski

29th May 2010

(I grabbed these scans from checkoutmycards.com but this post was inspired by Night Owl Cards.)

I am not a fan of this 1982 Donruss set but a lot of folks are. Like many sets by Topps from the 1970s and early 1980s, this set include some childish baseball imagery, specifically the baseball and bat that run across the bottom of each card. Of course, what I dislike is exactly what many other folks like.

There are some things I like about this set, though:

  • the prominent and retro Donruss logo (well, retro by today's standards)
  • the equally prominent year of '82, making it easy for kids to identify the set of origin
  • big photos that occupy most of the card with some border color variations, but the colors don't dominate the overall appearance of the card

Greg of Night Owl Cards made a lot of interesting observations about the photo used on this card. Click the link above to read it, but the summary is that the photo was probably taken in 1978. Greg used numerous clues about Yaz' uniform, including the pullover jersey, red helmet, and striped socks. Neat stuff.

There are a few other things I like about this specific photo:

  • Yaz is bunting. How cool is that?
  • He's got only one glove on. I can't find any other pictures of Yaz where he's got only one glove on.
  • Check out the people in the stands in the background. Still have any doubts that the photo was taken in the 1970s?

When I think about Yastrzemski's career, one of the first things that always comes to mind is his league-leading .301 batting average in 1968, a year of very low offense.

Here is that season for Yaz:

Year G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB
1968 157 664 539 90 162 32 2 23 74 119 90 .301 .426 .495 .922 170 267
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/28/2010.

He led the league in walks, BA, OBP, OPS, and OPS+.

Now 170 is a huge value for OPS+. To understand how this stat works, just look at Joe Mauer's stats from last year:

Rk Player PA OPS+ G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS
1 Joe Mauer 606 170 138 523 94 191 30 1 28 96 76 63 .365 .444 .587 1.031
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 5/28/2010.

Mauer is the only player to have an OPS+ of 170 in 2009. Whereas the 170 OPS+ was good for a .301 BA for Yaz in 1968, Mauer had to hit .365 to earn it last year. Yaz's raw OPS was .922 for a 170 OPS+ but Mauer's was 1.031.

This clearly illustrates why OPS+ is such a good stat. It bridges the gap across different seasons and conditions to demonstrate just how much above or below average a player was. Kids today who look at Yaz's BA in 1968 and see that .301 don't necessarily realize just how impressive it was that year. They just think he hit a lot less than Mauer did last year. Strictly this is true, but the real meaning goes beyond the raw numbers.

I'm looking for posts on card blogs to feature on the Card of the Week segment on the B-R blog. If you are an author or a fan of another card blog, please email me a link to the post you'd like me to consider. Ideally the post would include scans of the front and back of the card and contain some interesting or otherwise entertaining commentary.

My email address:

Posted in Card of the Week | 13 Comments »

Card of the Week: 1933 Goudey #9 Dave Harris

22nd May 2010

Images courtesy of Condition: Poor

The 1933 Goudey set is one of the grand-daddies of baseball card collecting. Goudey had been around as a chewing gum company for a while and became the first company to ever package baseball cards with bubble gum with this 1933 240-card release. The design might look quite familiar to modern-day collectors, as Upper Deck released a set a couple of years ago under the name Goudey that closely resembled this set.

The Dave Harris card shown above is quite typical of cards from this set. It's common to find cards that have been written on as back in 1933 kids were far more interested in the cards as a mechanism for learning and remembering modern-day players than as collectibles. As you can find on the source blog the L and F on the front were probably written by a kid who noted that Harris played left field. There's also a W in the lower right that at first looked to me like it was written on there, but it's actually the W on the sleeve of Harris' jersey.

On the back of the card (see scan below) we see "200", which might actually be a price of $2.00 written on the card sometime in the 1960s. (Amazing to think that somebody would write a price directly on a card, but that's the way it used to be.) It also appears that someone wrote "MAN." but I can't guess what that refers to. Harris was never a manager. Maybe he was just a man plain and simple?

In this condition, this card is worth at most a couple of bucks. There are numerous examples on eBay that are in better condition--similarly rounded corners but no writing, for example. Such cards go for $20-30.

One other thing--I am very surprised to see Harris' first name listed as "Dave." I was under the impression (mistakenly, obviously) that the nickname of Dave didn't come into common use until much later.

Harris had himself a nice career. He played parts of 7 seasons finishing with a 111 OPS+ in just under 1,700 plate appearances. His 1931 season was particularly good.

Rk Player Year PA RBI OPS+ Age Tm Lg G AB R H 2B 3B HR BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS Pos
1 Jose Canseco 1989 258 57 147 24 OAK AL 65 227 40 61 9 1 17 23 69 .269 .333 .542 .875 *9/D
2 Carlton Fisk 1988 298 50 155 40 CHW AL 76 253 37 70 8 1 19 37 40 .277 .377 .542 .919 *2
3 Johnny Grubb 1986 243 51 170 37 DET AL 81 210 32 70 13 1 13 28 28 .333 .412 .590 1.002 *D79
4 Oscar Gamble 1980 229 50 158 30 NYY AL 78 194 40 54 10 2 14 28 21 .278 .376 .567 .943 79D
5 Carlton Fisk 1975 294 52 150 27 BOS AL 79 263 47 87 14 4 10 27 32 .331 .395 .529 .923 *2/D
6 Willie McCovey 1962 261 54 154 24 SFG NL 91 229 41 67 6 1 20 29 35 .293 .368 .590 .957 739
7 Jerry Lynch 1961 210 50 167 30 CIN NL 96 181 33 57 13 2 13 27 25 .315 .407 .624 1.031 7/9
8 Johnny Blanchard 1961 275 54 168 28 NYY AL 93 243 38 74 10 1 21 27 28 .305 .382 .613 .995 *2/79
9 Dusty Rhodes 1954 186 50 182 27 NYG NL 82 164 31 56 7 3 15 18 25 .341 .410 .695 1.105 7/89
10 Ron Northey 1948 288 64 149 28 STL NL 96 246 40 79 10 1 13 38 25 .321 .420 .528 .949 *9
11 Don Padgett 1939 257 53 160 27 STL NL 92 233 38 93 15 3 5 18 11 .399 .444 .554 .998 *2/3
12 George Selkirk 1937 293 68 157 29 NYY AL 78 256 49 84 13 5 18 34 24 .328 .411 .629 1.040 *9
13 Dave Harris 1931 283 50 145 30 WSH AL 77 231 49 72 14 8 5 49 38 .312 .434 .506 .941 *9/7
14 Ben Paschal 1925 275 56 160 29 NYY AL 89 247 49 89 16 5 12 22 29 .360 .417 .611 1.028 978
15 Reb Russell 1922 250 75 175 33 PIT NL 60 220 51 81 14 8 12 14 18 .368 .423 .668 1.091 *9
16 Smoky Joe Wood 1921 229 60 151 31 CLE AL 66 194 32 71 16 5 4 25 17 .366 .438 .562 1.000 *98
17 Earl Smith 1921 261 51 147 24 NYG NL 89 229 35 77 8 4 10 27 8 .336 .409 .537 .946 *2
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 5/21/2010.

These are the only players since 1901 to have at least 50 RBI and an OPS+ of 145 in a season with no more than 300 plate appearances. I would think that most of these players were injured for part of the season as it would be tough to sit a guy powering to an OPS+ of 145 or better. As you can see, it's a list of impressive players.

Further reading:

Lots of baseball card blogs show examples of cards from this set. There is 240 Baseball Stars, a blog dedicated solely to the 1933 Goudey set. The author hasn't posted too much there yet.

Check out a 1933 Goudey Dale Alexander post at Mark's Ephemera.

Posted in Card of the Week | 8 Comments »

Card of the Week: 1977 O-Pee-Chee #210 George Scott

15th May 2010

(all images courtesy of oh my o-pee-chee! Click on images for larger versions)

Just about any card collector will know this, but in case you don't: O-Pee-Chee is the Canadian version of Topps. My understanding is that O-Pee-Chee was a Canadian company that utilized the Topps photographs and designs for card releases specifically in Canada. The sets were usually smaller, ignoring some of the non-star players, and sometimes the sets included extra players for the Canadian teams. See the "further reading" section at the end for more on this.

Another difference with the O-Pee-Chee set is that it was released later during the off-season than the Topps sets and this allowed the Canadian company to modify some of the cards to reflect off-season movement of the players. Brewers and Red Sox fans alike will recall that George Scott moved between the two teams during the off-season between the 1976 and 1977 seasons. This followed his earlier move between the same two teams between the 1971 and 1972 seasons.

Scott's trade will explain why the card above might look a little funny. If you still don't see it, take a look at his Topps card from the same year:

That's a real photo taken sometime in 1976 showing Scott in his Brewers' uniform and helmet. By the time O-Pee-Chee had produced its set, however, they had time to airbrush his jersey and helmet to reflect his trade to the Red Sox. (Note, however, that they kept his bling very much intact.) It's also interesting that they moved his signature.

The source blog for these scans and information is oh my o-pee-chee! (oh mon o-pee-chee!) written by GCRL, better known for the Garvey Cey Russell Lopes blog dedicated to Dodgers baseball cards. GCRL's O-Pee-Chee blog is focused on variations between cards due to modifications that O-Pee-Chee was able to make to the Topps designs each given year. If you enjoy this post about the George Scott card, you'll want to check out his blog because he has many, many more examples. You can also see the back of the Scott Topps card and see how it varies.

Speaking of card backs, if you check out the back of the Scott card below, you can immediately see one of the trademark differences between O-Pee-Chee and Topps. The Canadian company includes a French version of all the commentary on the card. Pretty cool--kids who spoke English as their first language could learn that "meilleur frappeur de puissance" means "best power hitter" in French.

I don't know all that much about Scott's career but I see he had two pretty lackluster years in his Age 24 and 25 seasons, putting up just 19 HR and 77 RBI in about 1,000 plate appearances across those two campaigns. That's a shame because if he had performed near his career average for those years, we can presume that he would have finished with 300 career HR and a batting average in the .270s.

Starting the next season, 1970, Scott was among the best power hitters in the game. Over his 8 peak years from 1970 to 1977, he was in the top 10 in HR:

Rk Player HR
1 Johnny Bench 245
2 Reggie Jackson 236
3 Willie Stargell 236
4 Lee May 226
5 Bobby Bonds 224
6 Graig Nettles 205
7 Hank Aaron 201
8 Tony Perez 199
9 George Scott 188
10 Reggie Smith 186
11 Willie McCovey 180
12 Billy Williams 177
13 Dave Kingman 176
14 Dick Allen 174
15 Bobby Murcer 174
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 5/14/2010.

Not to mention RBI:

Rk Player RBI
1 Johnny Bench 860
2 Tony Perez 803
3 Lee May 787
4 Reggie Jackson 736
5 Willie Stargell 727
6 Bobby Murcer 721
7 George Scott 699
8 Sal Bando 691
9 Rusty Staub 685
10 Bobby Bonds 681
11 Carl Yastrzemski 678
12 Bob Watson 672
13 Graig Nettles 665
14 Ted Simmons 661
15 Al Oliver 647
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 5/14/2010.

And it's amazing how times change. Scott was the Brewers' all-time slugging leader in 1977 with a .456 mark for the franchise. Nowadays that doesn't even crack the top 10:

Slugging %

Rank Player SLG PA
1. Ryan Braun .575 2012
2. Prince Fielder .542 2959
3. Richie Sexson .536 2288
4. Jeromy Burnitz .508 3269
5. Geoff Jenkins .496 4932
6. Cecil Cooper .470 6492
7. Corey Hart .468 2113
8. John Jaha .463 2530
9. Gorman Thomas .461 4133
10. Ben Oglivie .461 4658

However, this is one of the benefits of OPS+, which adjusts for overall offense levels in the league, among other things:

Adjusted OPS+

Rank Player OPS+ PA
1. Ryan Braun 146 2012
2. Prince Fielder 139 2959
3. Richie Sexson 133 2288
4. John Briggs 131 2237
5. George Scott 131 3320
6. Paul Molitor 125 8438
7. Sixto Lezcano 125 3132
8. Ben Oglivie 124 4658
9. Cecil Cooper 122 6492
10. Jeromy Burnitz 122 3269

Scott is 5th all-time in OPS+ for the Brewers, just ahead of HOFer Paul Molitor and just behind John Briggs, of whom I had never heard before writing this.

Further reading:

Back at my old card blog 88 Topps Cards I wrote all about the 1988 O-Pee-Chee set. You can also see some examples of cards featuring Blue Jays and Expos that were not included in the Topps set of the same year.

Posted in Card of the Week | 9 Comments »